This thread reminds me of a few years back when the SS pin cleaning was discovered and anyone who questioned the obvious superiority was a Luddite. I recently relented and went that route myself but am now considering a hybrid method using wet cleaning without pins followed by dry tumbling to polish. I read about that here on another thread and seems to be a good compromise. So far I have seen no evidence that clean case interiors and primer pockets reduce chrony SD's but I will give it another feww hundred cases to be fair. But back to what we call annealing but on metallurgy sites is called stress relief.
One thing for certain is time is definite factor. I am not sure you can take a piece of brass up to 700 for 1 second remove the heat source and call it annealed. While I have yet to find this on a scientific paper with a chart showing time vs temp. Most people on the bench shooting sites agree that 7 seconds at 700F is the sweet spot for stress relieving brass, I would like to find that documented somewhere other than a blog however. That might be possible with a high end inductance machine that used a IR thermometer to throttle the coil heat or switched it on or off as needed. All the cases would have to have a equal polish of course for that to work.
Waiting on parts coming from China to build a automated system and as usual went with a cheaper and easier solution. Buying breakout boards and playing with Arduino is a bit of overkill for what I want to do so what I am thinking of doing is KISS and just doing 2 indicators on two cases. The first at 700 would give me a "start" time and then do a second case with a 800 or 850 indicator would be the "stop time". Since the stress relief is logarithmic not linear that means those two times could only be 2 or 3 seconds apart it should still provide the desired effect. I also think even if it is just close at least it will consistent if automated. It would be nice however to find a chart that shows how many seconds at 700, 725, 750 etc is required.
The brass does not care if that heat gets there in a second or five seconds as long as you don't let it go too far down past the neck. The trick is to keep the heat on long enough to have an effect but not so long you lose the spring back and at the same time fast enough you get shoulders collapsing from softening. I think I can do that with gas
One thing for certain is time is definite factor. I am not sure you can take a piece of brass up to 700 for 1 second remove the heat source and call it annealed. While I have yet to find this on a scientific paper with a chart showing time vs temp. Most people on the bench shooting sites agree that 7 seconds at 700F is the sweet spot for stress relieving brass, I would like to find that documented somewhere other than a blog however. That might be possible with a high end inductance machine that used a IR thermometer to throttle the coil heat or switched it on or off as needed. All the cases would have to have a equal polish of course for that to work.
Waiting on parts coming from China to build a automated system and as usual went with a cheaper and easier solution. Buying breakout boards and playing with Arduino is a bit of overkill for what I want to do so what I am thinking of doing is KISS and just doing 2 indicators on two cases. The first at 700 would give me a "start" time and then do a second case with a 800 or 850 indicator would be the "stop time". Since the stress relief is logarithmic not linear that means those two times could only be 2 or 3 seconds apart it should still provide the desired effect. I also think even if it is just close at least it will consistent if automated. It would be nice however to find a chart that shows how many seconds at 700, 725, 750 etc is required.
The brass does not care if that heat gets there in a second or five seconds as long as you don't let it go too far down past the neck. The trick is to keep the heat on long enough to have an effect but not so long you lose the spring back and at the same time fast enough you get shoulders collapsing from softening. I think I can do that with gas
Last edited: