Actually, OC and mace are two different things. Mace is an older chemical CN. OC is oleoresin capsicum and is derived from peppers. The two have similar yet different effects. OC is generally accepted as more effective. However, OC has an effectiveness of between 70 & 90 percent depending on whose stuidies you believe. It is acknowledged to be less effective on people who are drunk, stoned, insane or with high levels of adrenaline and in fact has been shown to make some people more aggressive.
Not sure what point you were going for here, unless it was to repeat what I had just written.
My point was that your statement seems to be that those who avoid confrontations are "hiding behind" their ccw.
I have seen several guys I was in the military with take people out with one punch on a regular basis, even guys who were much bigger than them. Your statement makes the (possibly fatal) assumption that anyone you face will be an "average moron", drunk and/or less well trained than you. That will not always be the case.
I couldn't agree with this more, but if I am engaged by an asailant and do not percieve a need to draw and cannot truly retreat, why pull my sidearm when a blast of 5.3 million SHU will do the trick?
Because OC is almost as likely not to do the trick. If you are in danger of serious bodily harm or death, you should use deadly force. If you are not in fear of serious bodily harm or death you should walk away. Generally if a situation only calls for LTL, then you still have the option of retreating. How could anyone not think that a physical assault on you after blocking your retreat could be anything but life threatening? Of course, this only applies to civilians, not LEO, bouncers, security officers, etc..
This is also very true. What happens, though, if you shoot some gangbanger at a club or something. Doesn't matter where, could be in the middle of a parking lot. What happens if you shoot said gangbanger and his friends, seeing your "hero" faceon the news, come put a few hundred rounds down range into your house and your family? Now what do you do? LTL could have avoided that. That is purely hypothetical, but we live in a society where the bad people have a better chance at getting the guns. Talk about meeting someone who is badder.
You're right, it is purely hypothetical to the point that it really doesn't warrant consideration. You don't have to have your face on tv, the fact is that the odds of you using a firearm for defense are incredibly small, the odds of using it on a gangbanger even smaller and the odds of his buddies retaliation smaller still. However it is worth commenting again on the "magic bullet" that some claim OC to be. It is not. Read the last issue of Police News. Those are the exact words: " . . . not the magic bullet everyone first thought it to be."
If you choose to carry LTL for moral reasons that's fine. But it is better to have the mindset that if it is not worth taking a life over, it is not worth getting involved in.