3 must own handguns?

Small

Medium

Large
This. More specifically:
1. A .22 revolver. I think the Ruger Bearcat would fit the bill for reliability (don't trust semi .22s b/c of rimfire duds).
2. This one's a little tougher because "medium" could mean a lot of different things. 9mm/.38SP/.40 (CZ P-01 or Smith K/L frame for me)
3. Also difficult. Some think .357mag is "large" in terms of power; I'm partial to calibers that start with a number 4 for this task. .44mag and .45Colt.
 
1) S&W 22 revolver or 1911 with Marvel 22 conversion or maybe Keltec PF9 with 22 conversion!
2) SP101 3" 357 mag
3) Glock 20

Don't Have a S&W 22.:(
My Marvel/1911 conversion = Full size 45 and competition level 22.
My Twisted Industries/Keltec conversion = Pocket 9mm and good plinker 22.
Tough choice on the 22!:confused:
 
#1) 1911 in 45 acp with a 22 conversion kit

#2) Big revolver (.357, .45 colt, .44 mag) in the make and model of your choice

#3) Plastic gun of your choice (glock, S&W M&P, SA XD...)
 
I have probably said this a thousand times but like everything else in life, it depends. It depends on what you plan to do with them and of course, personal preference.

Imo, here are the basic categories.

1) a good 22, everybody needs one
2) concealed carry
3) home defense
4) small game hunting
5) big game hunting
6) competition, lots of variation here depending on how and where you compete

Obviously, not all these apply to everyone and some guns can cover multiple categories and revolver vs semiauto is largely personal preference. So, if limited to three...

1) a good 22, this can also covers small game hunting
2) a concealed carry gun, whatever works for you and this can also cover home defense
3) a big bore for hunting big game, this can also likely cover home defense with proper ammo
 
1911 mil spec 45.

Dan Wesson 357 Mag Pistol Pack

Thompson Center Contender.

Honorable Mention

TZ 75 9mm
Ruger MK? 22lr.
 
Why 3?

Having read through 5 pages of nearly identical suggestions, varying mostly in specific model or caliber, along with a few rediculous suggestions as "must own", here's my opinion.

For "must own" handguns (upper limit 3, although I have no idea why), they would be

1) a .22LR
2) a centerfire revolver
3) a centerfire semiautomatic

I have phrased it this way because for someone getting into handgun ownership, any make and model of each category is sufficient to educate the new handgunner on basic operating and safety principles, and particularly the .22 (in what ever action style preferred) allows for the cheapest, easiest training and practice.

The low cost ammo, low recoil and muzzle blast of a .22 pistol allows beginners to get familiar, and develope needed skills without the cost and risks of larger calibers. Being able to fire 500 shots in practice for the cost of 50 (or even 20) larger caliber rounds is benefical to the beginner, and experienced shooters alike.

Note that I said nothing about specific calibers, makes and models, beyond the .22LR, because I don't feel any specific centerfire gun, barrel length, & caliber belongs on a must own list.

The guns you must own (as a begininer) are the ones that you will learn on. )Ones that will teach you the raw basics of handgun shooting, and the differences in general type (revolver vs auto). Once you have learned the basics, you will develop likes and dislikes, and an awareness of what comes easily to you, and what you will have to work at to master.

Then, when you have some ideas about which calibers, sizes, styles and types will fill both your needs and wants, you can get something best suited for the specifics you want.

Or, you could wind up like me, spending decades collecting numerous handguns, each time being certain that it was one I must own.....:D

1. A .22 revolver. I think the Ruger Bearcat would fit the bill for reliability (don't trust semi .22s b/c of rimfire duds).

As to this, you get duds in revolvers, too. The difference is, with a revolver, you can usually go on and shoot the rest of the rounds, then take care of the dud. With an auto, you must take care of the dud in order to shoot the rest of the rounds!
 
For people with normal amounts of money:
- .22 Revolver
- a bigger caliber revolver, atleast a .357 mag
- AK47 pistol, such as a Draco or Mini Draco

With those with large amounts of money
- Magnum Research Desert Eagle in .44 or .50
- Magnum Research BFR in .45-70 (my dream handgun)
- either a .22 revolver or an AK47 pistol
 
I can't see putting an AK pistol (or any other specialty piece like it) on a "must own" list. Same for the Desert Eagle (which I do own).

nice to have, if you like it, but a "must own"?

no.
 
I like AK pistols, pretty fun and cheap to shoot. And if I had money, I'd love to own a Desert Eagle and a BFR. They're on my dream list.
 
A Ruger 22 mk or 22/45
And 2 Glock or 2 XD that are the same. These 2 of the exact same count as one.
A Smith or Ruger revolver.

In the early 70s the almost universal wish list was a Colt Python, a Colt Gold Cup and a Browning Hi power.
 
I'm suprised that no one has mentioned the Ruger SP101 in 22lr for their choice of a 22 revolver. It's a great revolver. Well worth the money.
 
Three must own....
1) A large caliber Magnum revolver, stainless. .357/.44/.500 whatever. They are things of beauty and fun to shoot.
2) A reliable semi-auto for Concealed Carry. Size doesn't matter as long as you can carry it without printing.
3) A gun that you know you will never part with. One that is comfortable, you shoot well, and love the looks of. For me it is my 92FS.

.22's are fun, but I don't think they are "must haves" (although a 22 rifle is a must-have, just not a handgun IMO). 1911s are great looking, but are pretty uncomfortable for me to shoot, so I can't put them on the must-have list either.
 
Back
Top