which Colt ?

[Tommy Vercetti]

would you rather have ? a Python or a Commander ?

now just to make it interesting..if you didn't have any handguns

 

[trigger happy]

ooh tough one..I chose the Commander

 

[Ala Dan]

No Handguns?

Tommy Ole' Bud

You have made things VERY interesting, my friend. I'm an old revolver
geek from way back; but after a successful career in law enforcement,
I have become attached to guns chambered for the .45 ACP. Mainly,
the SIG-SAUER P220A; but more recently the 1911's. So, with that
said I'm gonna have too vote for the Colt Commander~!

 

[ddskehan]

had them both. now only one. see list below

 

[RickB]

I lept before I looked; I already have a Commander, so you could say, based on that, that I would rather have a Commander. But, also based on that, you could surmise that I'd want a Python.

 

[Easy E]

Given your criteria...

I'de go for the .45 Commander. It would simply be a more practical tool for me.

 

[Pointer]

I voted Commander...

But truth is I'd rather have a Springfield 1911 with night sights, alloy-light frame, a much better, crisp factory trigger than...

A Colt 1991A1 without these things...

At less money!!

 

[cheygriz]

A python is kind of the "ultimate" revolver. For a pistol enthusiast to own a Pyrhon is kind of like a Rifle enthusiast owning a double H&H rifle. There's the "class" factor!

 

[solz56]

I've been lusting after some 1911 variants lately including the Commander. So that's how I'm voting.

 

[whitebb]

Fine,I will be the only one here: I want the Python. I love wheel guns. .45ACP's are nice, but they are second fiddle in my eyes to .357. (My next purchase will be a 1911) My Colt king Cobra is as close to a Python as I will get, unless I find a great deal on one.

 

[trigger happy]

I am actually considering a Commander

 

[steelheart]

I'd rather have the Commander for carry and home defense, the Python for range shooting and fun.

 

[namnuts]

Which Colt?

WOW, I had this same problem 20 years ago, so I just bought them both. Since then i've added 3 more Colt autos, and one more Pyhton. REMBER, IF IT'S A COLT IT'S A CLONE!!!!!
NAMNUTS
Semper Fi

 

[2ndamd]

I just can not get away from the versatility of a .357 mag revolver. Gotta go with Python if it is only one. If you can have more than one......buy both.

 

[Doug.38PR]

Revolver

 

[trigger happy]

if I could find them both I'd buy them both

 

[Kermit]

I'd go /w a vintage Python...blue 6"

 

[tony pasley]

which?

well if they are giving it away python the sell it get a commanderand have plenty of change left over. if i have to buy a commander

 

[stevelyn]

The Python.

If it's a Commander style .45 you want, there are plenty of monkeys cobbling them together that are much better than the Colt version.

 

[trigger happy]

I know..right

too bad that's mostly true