Personally IMO unless you are shooting competitively I would say no. In some cases these high end 1911's aren't the best choice for defensive guns. Alot of high end 1911's have tighter tolerances which are great for accuracy but can suffer in reliability if they get a bit dirty, and some may not feed HP's as well as even some of their cheaper counterparts. There is a reason milspec guns have looser tolerances than some other guns on the market, and that's for reliabilities sake.
One of the many nice things about a custom gun is that your intended use is taken into consideration when it's built and it is set up accordingly. High end, custom, reliability, accuracy, appearance, and so on, are not mutually exclusive. You can have everything you want, you just have to find someone that can build it.
Not really sure what you mean by "drive by statement" but when a company has been known as a semi-custom 1911 shop for 15-20 years, by the vast majority of the industry, and someone comes along and says "no they are production line 1911s" it just sounds rather goofy to me.
The problem with the term "semi-custom" is that it's so ambiguous. I mean, what's "semi" anything? I used cars in my example because, like some "semi-custom" 1911s, you have a list of options to choose from, but selecting a different color paint or interior or a bigger engine doesn't make it a custom car. Limited production may be a better term. Ducati builds some motorcycles that they only make a very small number of each year, limited production models that get more attention and higher end parts and accessories than the other motorcycles coming off the line but it's not considered a custom or semi-custom, how can it be? There's another one just like it parked right next to it and they'll make more just like those.
Now, that's not to say that some of those same companies won't build you a true custom gun, either using your own piece as a foundation or one of theirs. As I understand it, the Colt custom shop will build pretty much anything you want, same with Springfield's, and I think Wilson may still take on custom builds. I'm sure that other high end manufacturers will as well.
So, you (or the industry) can use whatever term you want but I calls 'em the way I sees 'em and there isn't much, if any, custom about most "semi-custom" guns. They're really nice, expensive, accurate, well fitted, well finished, but not custom. And there's not a thing wrong with that, look through the catalog and if one of them fits you're needs then you're all set.
I love that pistol, WC - your guy does unbelievable work. When it comes to aesthetics, that Officers Model of yours is #1 in my book. I'm sure it shoots as good as it looks.
Thanks. And, yes, it does shoot as good as it looks.
Please do. I don't know who he is, but it's pretty uncommon for a picture of a gun to really make me go "Wow." But the ones we've seen here have been nothing short of spectacular.
To be honest, I like it better with these grips than the others. She's just gorgeous! If I were looking to have a melt job done on a 1911, I'd be bugging you for your smith's name.
I will, and thanks. I agree with you on the grips, I really liked the stags but I think the clean, simple look of these make for a nice contrast against the rest of the gun (just wish I could remember what kind they are
)
The shine on that gun is just stunning! I can almost see myself in it and I am looking at it on a laptop. LOL
So what Smith did the melt job?
That gun is the product of two shops. Clarks did their Meltdown package on it back in '98 shortly after they started doing them. The melts were more radical then, the ones they've been doing for several years now look more like the Kimber CDP. I think people must find them more palatable that way.
Anyway, Clarks parkerized it after they did the work and when I got the gun it hadn't had many rounds through it but it had been carried a lot and the finish was worn and it looked bad, especially with the ORM 1991A1 billboard rollmarks. It shot great and was perfectly reliable, just like you'd expect a Clark gun would be. I carried it like that for a while then took it to Dietrich Gunsmithy in Otis, ME to be refinished. Robin Dietrich is the gunsmith and he's a very talented young guy (he's only 27). I had him clean the rollmarks off the slide, fit a checkered S&A MSH, hand checker the front strap, do an 11deg crown on the barrel, bead blast the sights and put a brass insert in the front, then polish the gun and the barrel to a mirror finish and blue it. It turned out better than either of us expected and still shoots just like it did before.
The full size gun in the other picture is also an ORM 1991A1, a .38 Super. Robin did the build on that gun, everything except the finish, which is Ionbond DLC. That one is neat because in addition to the Super barrel it also has 9mm and 9x23 Winchester barrels fitted to it.
This is what the Meltdown looked like before it was refinished-