Active shooter scenario in a public place (Oregon mall)

Is there a detailed account of what and where the gunman did the shooting . I ask cus the CCW guy says he heard 3 shots the gun jammed and then he believes the gunman took his own life with one more shot . That is a total of 4 shots fired . Is that the official count . If not why did he not hear the other shots . Might be a way of confirming his story .

I would think it's unlikely anyone saw him pull his gun they all were running ducking for cover or looking at the gunman rather then others around them .

Finding the friends he was with and them confirming the story would go a long ways .
 
That is a total of 4 shots fired . Is that the official count . If not why did he not hear the other shots . Might be a way of confirming his story .
Click to expand...

Early reports said 60 shots fired.....
 
Surprised it hasn't been mentioned yet (unless I missed it) but there was an armed CHL holder in the mall who chose not to fire due to bystanders.

http://www.nwcn.com/news/oregon/183609901.html

Meli, who has a concealed carry permit, positioned himself behind a pillar.

"He was working on his rifle," said Meli. "He kept pulling the charging handle and hitting the side."

The break in gunfire allowed Meli to pull out his own gun, but he never took his eyes off the shooter.

"As I was going down to pull I saw someone in the back of the charlotte move and I knew if I fired and missed I could hit them."

Meli took cover inside a nearby store. He never pulled the trigger. He stands by that decision.
Click to expand...

Edit: I definitely missed the whole last page of discussion. lol :rolleyes:
 
I read in one of the posts that the police dont train for an active shooter situation. They do. It may not be called "ACTIVE SHOOTER" but police train for, and deal with "man with a gun" calls all the time. The difference is some departments when confronted with an active shooter would wait for SWAT or some special unit leaving the shooter to have his way with the victims.

My department had no such policy. If we responded to a man with a gun call, we would investigate and attempt to apprehend or shoot the shooter. At the same time calling in the troops. Coordinating response, covering exits, and using every approach. Police 101. 99% of the time a 911 operator would keep a caller on the line feeding us information such as location and description of the shooter, victims needing aid, descriptions of others involved. Shooters active or otherwise would be dealt with the officers assigned to the call, or the first back up unit on the scene. If the situation becomes a hostage situation then the Emergency Services (swat) would take over along with a negotiator. If the situation became prolonged or there was a need for a detailed search, the first responding officers would be relieved by ESS officers if possible.

As far as an armed non-sworn civilian, or an off duty officer... If I was either... I'd probably take the shot.

For those who would take off... I'd advise looking for emergency exit signage. I'd advise against going to the parking lot or main mall entrance. It may be an organized operation by trained terrorists. It's a tactic they use to draw in the emergency responders en masse, along with spectators, and victims recieving aid. Then detonate a powerfull bomb. That being the main event, and the shooting just a way to draw in the actual targets
 
Im not sure about the ccw carrier that had opportunity to end the massacre not engaging. From the little i read on the post the crazy was dealing with a malfunctioning weapon at least for a moment two.
The decision not to engage in case of a miss and someone fleeting behind the nut job somehow doesnt make muster. I wasnt there so this arm chair quarter backing but, faced with a mass shooter intent on killing more people and offered a chance to stop him from likely killing several to many more innocents vs the chance I might miss and hit someone I saw MOVING behind him and quite possibly out of the way by the time I fired I believe I would engage.
As I say I wasnt there have limited knowledge of the whole shooting encounter but based on just that I dont think I could do nothing and retreat in that exact situation and allow the killing to continue.
 
What I want to know is: in this exact situation would it still be considered self defense to take the shot if the mall shooter was busy clearing a jam?
 
No lawyer here but in my state you have the right to defend a third party from serious injury or death. Even lacking that your still faced with self defense. In this case we are talking about someone who has already in fact attacked with lethal force stopped only by a weapon malfunction and in the process of clearing that, leaving any reasonable person with every reason to believe he intends to continue killing.
 
What I want to know is: in this exact situation would it still be considered self defense to take the shot if the mall shooter was busy clearing a jam?
Click to expand...

No prosecutor around here would indict, and no jury herabouts would convict someone who killed someone who was clearing a jammed weapon so he could keep killing more people.

YMMV. If it does, your locality has some serious issues with it's justice system.
 
I still want to hear why (though I think I know why) I have not heard more about Mr. Meli's actions in the MSM .......

....if we do, Mr. Meli will be mentioned as a "security guard", not as a private citizen.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
No prosecutor around here would indict, and no jury herabouts would convict someone who killed someone who was clearing a jammed weapon so he could keep killing more people.

YMMV. If it does, your locality has some serious issues with it's justice system.
Click to expand...

welcome to NJ!

you didn't take your opportunity to retreat, now you're in the frying pan:mad:
 
I was shocked last night when I was watching CNN and a 2A supporter was engaging the host and mentioned the citizen's involvement in this incident. Of course I came here and read the last page of replies for details. I am outraged that this hasn't been mentioned in the mainstream media (but I'm not shocked). The host of the show (Piers Morgan) actually said that no civilian/ armed citizen has ever stopped a mass shooting and that it is a "myth" that it has been done.
I would highly encurage anyone on this board who knows of a story or has a link to a news report of a citizen stopping a shooter to please e-mail it to Mr. Morgan at CNN.
 
he host of the show (Piers Morgan) actually said that no civilian/ armed citizen has ever stopped a mass shooting and that it is a "myth" that it has been done.
Click to expand...

Perhaps you could supply some links.

I only recall one incident, where a school employee went out to his car to retrieve a weapon. Can't remember whether that person actually stopped the shooting.

In other cases the shooting was stopped by unarmed students or adults and by private security as in the attempted church shooting.
 
Don't forget the Colorado church incident. In the case mentioned in Arkansas, IIRC - the vice principal retrieved his firearm and stopped the shooter from fleeing.
 
  1. Pearl High School in Pearl, Mississippi. The assistant principal got his gun from his car, and he confronted and stopped the shooter.

  2. Appalachian School of Law shooting. However, in that case the students who got their guns from their cars also happened to be LEOs.

  3. Aurora, CO church shooting, April, 2012. The fellow who stopped it was an off duty police officer.
Of course a primary reason why more rampage shootings aren't stopped by a potential victim with a gun is that rampage shooters seem to be pretty good about choosing places in which they won't find any potential victims with a gun.
 
Give you a hint about calling 9/11 to describe you are armed in the middle of a fire fight.

The police on the scene will likely get a call that one of the guys with a gun is YOU.

It probably won't be transmitted that you are a hero. Listen to some tapes of miscommunication sometime.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top