9mm, 40 s&w, 45 acp shot to shot recovery test

Evil Monkey said:
Shooting an unmodified, normal defense pistol, that fast will usually have the second round fired anywhere except the target. So it doesn't matter if you can "outrun" the trigger/slide because in that time frame you have to get the sight picture straight before you pull the trigger again.
Click to expand...

I'd argue that what you describe above has more to do with poor technique than the effect of recoil...

WildBill acknowledged that there was a difference in the amount of recoil seen or experienced between the three calibers, but went on to say that differences in the real world probably has more to do with the shooter's experience, prejudices and expectations than a profound difference in the actual amount of a gun barrel rises as the gun cycles.

I think he's right.

Having been a safety officer and a person who scored many targets at many IDPA matches, I can tell you that some folks shooting .45s can do things much more quickly than folks shooting 9mms. Almost any semiauto, if the shooter is using good technique, can be back down and ready to fire before the shooter has acquired the target and squeezed the trigger. If the second shot is off target, it's arguably not due to recoil.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the time and effort put into the video.

I enjoyed watching it, and the video makes it pretty evident that caliber, when it comes to recovery, doesn't matter.
 
Thanks for the video wildbill. Hickok45 did a recovery / speed video on the g26 vs g27 and another on 9,40,10 if I remember right. There seemed like a huge difference in those videos. I think he favors the 40, so the faster follow up on the 9 just was what it was. Always nice to see videos like this.
 
I have to disagree here...... what the video showed is that there is little difference in recovery time for you but you have the shooting experience, strength and obviously the body size that it makes no difference. Now if your camera person who sounded female were to do the same video the results may be difference. What it comes down to is that for each of us there is a maximum caliber that we can handle and below that recovery time is of little consequence.
 
I dare you.

Bring it or shut up.
Click to expand...

:D

Even if I did come down there, I don't think your dad would let you take his guns to the range with your school friends to have a chest puffing competition with some stranger.

I'd argue that what you describe above has more to do with poor technique than the effect of recoil...
Click to expand...

There's two steps you must do after firing your first shot:

1. Point the pistol forward again towards the target.

2. Reacquire the sights on target

Reacquisition speed can vary from person to person and can be worked on for improvement. Recoil forces and grip shifting in hand with common defense calibers in most pistols won't matter a whole lot. Reacquisition takes more time than pointing the pistol forward after firing the first shot. Inherently, you can't outrun a pistols cyclic action unless you planned on the second round being a complete miss.

So no, I don't believe any of that crap about outrunning or nearly outrunning a normal defense pistols cyclic action and still having an accurate second shot. Outside of raceguns, it's BS.
 
Now if your camera person who sounded female were to do the same video the results may be difference.
Click to expand...

No question about that, she is fairly new to guns and cameras!:) The demo was to show the guns can work the spectrum, but the shooters have to match up within their own skill sets but, don't blame the gun.
 
but the shooters have to match up within their own skill sets but, don't blame the gun.
Click to expand...

I'm not sure a shooter saying he/she can shoot one caliber or another faster is "blaming the gun". For some it's just their reality. I can shoot a 9mm faster than a 40SW. I don't blame the guns, but that is my reality.
 
I think WildBill established that with his skill set it really doesn't matter what he shot. On the other hand those with lesser skills it might matter.
 
There are MANY factors that impact recoil and recovery to point of aim after each shot. Heck, choice of powder can drastically change felt recoil from the same gun, same bullet weight and same muzzle velocity. You can make super soft shooting rounds that make major with miniscule quantities fast powders that have negligible recoil. Or change to a big amount of slow powder and at the same power level have lots of recoil.


But yes, in general if all calibers are shot at the same speed and you customize the loading for minimal recoil the lighter bullets have less recoil and faster recovery. But.... if you set the same POWER LEVEL and optimize each, the heavier caliber may well shoot softest. That's why competition shooters needing major power factor shoot 40 and not 9.

Confused?:D
 
Good effort WildBill45. I agree it would have been nice to have been done with the same platform. It would have been good to see the targets you were shooting at. Either a second camera or have the one camera pan right over to each target after the two shots. Follow up speed is one thing, it's another thing to be accurate with follow up shots. Not saying yours were not though.

One other thing that would have been nice in the clip is what load specs were used for each cartridge.
 
In a full size handgun, it's not as much of an issue. When you get into smaller compact carry guns, it becomes a whole new ball game.

With that said, less recoil equates to flatter shooting and quicker followup shots, I don't care how advanced your skill set is.
 
It would have been good to see the targets you were shooting at.
Click to expand...

The target was good but not up to everyday standards as my mind was on control only using the x ring as an aiming point. If you have seen my Glock 41 vs my Glock 30S video I did ok on paper and it is seen... This was just a fun test to show newbies to not fear a gun they may like due to others opine that my be accurate or may be less than accurate. If you don't tell someone they can't do it, most of the time they will do it!!! :D
 
I always appreciate, and enjoy WildBill's videos. From accuracy with Hi-Points, and mouse guns to debunking the recovery myth I think his username should be RealBill45.:D
 
I think WildBill established that with his skill set it really doesn't matter what he shot. On the other hand those with lesser skills it might matter.
Click to expand...

I'm sorry I'm still of the opinion it's generally faster to shoot 9mm than 40SW while maintaining the same group sizes. Now the time difference for a skilled shooter might be miniscule, but I'd be amazed to see it not there at all.

While I also agree skill is one thing, Hartcreek brought up the notion of body size. When the FBI transitioned to 10mm they found smaller statured shooters and women were having difficulty with both the size of the gun and the recoil. A larger individual might not have that problem.

The target was good but not up to everyday standards as my mind was on control only using the x ring as an aiming point. If you have seen my Glock 41 vs my Glock 30S video I did ok on paper and it is seen...
Click to expand...

I don't think Worc was questioning your skill, more wondering if you could keep the same group sizes at the same speed across those calibers.

With that said, less recoil equates to flatter shooting and quicker followup shots, I don't care how advanced your skill set is.
Click to expand...

To me this is bingo. I don't think anyone here would question that they could shoot a 22LR pistol faster while maintaining the same group size as compared to a larger caliber. A skilled shooter of good strength can control any caliber, but how the rounds impact the target is important too.
 
Last edited:
Less power should equal more control
Click to expand...

All day long, but the point was and for CCW folks who normally carry standard ammo specs and standard guns. I was not talking race guns, handloaded ammo to meet a need by a specific shooter.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top