The "Perfect Pistol" - how would you design one?

THIS IS A WISH LIST - RIGHT?

Glock is a near to prefect as you can get in my book, but there are still a few changes I would make – something along the lines of Glock with XD/Sigma/STI hybrid characteristics.

XD/Sigma – Pistol can be narrowed a bit while maintaining capacity by going to metal magazine like the XD and get the better ergonomics of the Sigma. That is about the only thing worth a damn on a Sigma

XD - Trigger face more like the XD with a dished grove in the inside center of the trigger guard to prevent pinching.

XD/1911 – Grip safety that does not affect the trigger pull. I like the XD’s narrow unobtrusive grip safety that makes the gun truly drop safe and ensure safe holstering by raising your thumb over to the back of the slide. No matter what might accidently catch the trigger in a fall or when holstering, it can’t go bang unless it depresses the grip safety at the same time.

Glock Gen II and Sigma - Loose the square trigger guard (Sigma) and thumb rest indentations (Glock Gen II)

STI – modular poly body with frame insert. This would have number of benefits. You could have different configuration bodies by color, grip vs dust cover length, grip style, accessory rail vs no rail. In addition a fat version of the frame could be made that has to be reduced down just a bit to fit in the slide grooves. Allows a tighter gun and eliminates some trigger creep inherent in a Glock. Sort of like the new Sig 250.

STI – optional manual safety that optionally stays disengaged once the action starts, meaning it must be push in slightly from the other side go back to safe. Sounds a little nuts I know, but it means you would never have to worry about the manual safety accidently being engaged in the heat of battle when you don’t want it to. Manual safety would have to, when engaged, allow cycling of the slide for chamber check and unloading

Factory trigger stop build on a poly bushing that would stop the trigger after striker release, but still allow additional pressure to fire it should it shift a little forward.

Rear sights moved all the way completely to the rear, adjustable and with a hard angle up front for one handed slide cycling. I don’t give a flip about how smooth it is to reholster.

Friction adjustment screw that would allow the user to set his gun up with non drop free magazine features. This device when properly adjusted would only allow the magazine to freely drop about one inch when the mag release button is pushed. Beyond that, it must be physically pulled from the mag well against about 3-lbs of friction. If a mag was accidently released it would still be in the gun when you figured out and had a misfire. It would be there for you in your Roll Tap & Rack.

Nose would be reduced down like a Browning Hi-Power.

Progressive rifling, meaning the rifling doesn’t twist at all for about the first two inches and then gradually increase up to the required twist rate within the next two inches. Additionally the straight rifling starts off low and then gradually rises before turning This should increase velocity and lower chamber pressure. Barrel should also come from factory electrically or extruded polished and cryogenically treated.

Factory .22 conversion kit with high capacity magazines and sight cuts exactly like center fire slides.

Grip plug as factory part.

Frame dished out slighted at mag release button to allow thumb better acces while still protecting button

Must retain Glock's ability to remove mag in doubl feed without locking slide to the rear.

Plactic grips would cost $25 each in what ever configuration you wanted or color you wanted, and
 
Something else you might want to add onto the list if you're designing a new gun - ease and cost of manufacture.
 
The "Perfect Pistol" - how would you design one?

I'll play...
* It has the dimensions of a Kahr P9 or T9

* It weighs no more than 20 oz.

* It has no external safety.

* It is hammer fired.

* A double action trigger with a lever/button to switch from heavy to light trigger pull ( say 8# to 4#). Think adjustable LEM.

* It has a HK/Walther style mag release.

* It is a 7 or 8 round mag...maybe a slight stagger.

* It comes with night sights.

* It costs under $800.

* 9mm, .357 sig, .40s&w... all in one gun...swap the barrel...done.
 
30 round capacity
Full auto capabilities
45 ACP
Indestructable
Dead-on accurate
Simple to use
Beautiful to look at
Full-sized
Stainless slide and frame cover with nitron
smooth 5 round trigger pull
 
I already own both -

Revolver - Colt Python - Blue - 6" Barrel

Automatic - Colt Gold Cup National Match - Stainless Steel
 
I thought the Smith & Wesson model 650 .22 magnum was perfect, so is the 649 Bodyguard (unless it has a lock) and my personal favorite the Colt Cobra in nickel
 
I would design a revolver-auto crossover.It would have the long trigger pull,and no safty of a revolver,yet use a double stacked magazine.
 
Microgunner, here is the "Perfect Pistol."

Microgunner, this might not be exactly what your looking for, but its about as close as your going to get in the 50 Cal range. I do this in my spare time as a hobby. This seemed like a good opportunity to share it.
 

Attachments

  • 50Cal.jpg
    50Cal.jpg
    77.5 KB · Views: 15
Well, I'm glad you asked. I thought about this for a long time.

Full-size
Polymer framed
Hammer fired
Double-stacked
Chambered in 9mm
19 or 20 round capacity (like the Beretta 92 or XDm 9mm)
Hopefully between 28 and 32 ounces unloaded (I like something a "tad" bith heavier than a glock)
Picatinny Rail
Made from the ground up to handle the beating of 9mm +p+
1911 grip angle
Double action/single action
H&K USP style safety/decocker (both cocked and locked or just locked or not locked)

Now, you might think, "Hey! Besides the capacity, he pretty much just describe the H&K USP."

But, here are the things that will really differentiate it...

Baby Eagle style bore axis (much lower than H&K, Sig, or XD)
Glock-style site radius (at the extreme ends of the slide)
5" match barrel with polygonal rifling
Replaceable slide rails (such as those found on the FNP)
A nice, tough finish (Rogard maybe?)

Alright, in my tiny little brain, this actually seems to be manufacturable. So, someone, make me one! :-)
 
A perfect pistol? You mean like the one gun to rule them all?

I'll keep my imperfect guns thankyou. That's what makes buying new and different models so much fun! ...Trying to take the joy out of ole Willie's life is what you are doin'.;)
 
Hi, Everyone....long-time lurker, first-time posting!

One of my perfect pistols would be a thinner Beretta Tomcat in .380 with a frame that was not prone to cracking. DA/SA with a manual safety for those occasions when you need it.
 
Revolver wise its alreday done. A S&W 29-2 or earlier, blued, 4 or 6.5 inch barrel wearing Coke bottles. For now I'm making due with some 629s and a 29-3 but someday.
Semi wise. If Ruger could do the SR-9 in 10mm without changing anything in the grip area, I'd buy the first one I could find.
 
Back
Top