My vote is for the .35 Whelen. I have three rifles so chambered although two now live in the safe. My go to rifle is a custom Mauser .35 Whelen had made up with a 1 in 14" twist. I almost passed on the gun because it wasn't a 1 in 12" twist but it was so pretty, fit me so well that I said I'll gamble on that twist and the devil take the hindmost. That rifle has been on six elk hunts since I bought it and has put down six elk, either DRT or so incapacitated that they could not get up and try to run off. Those elk were shot at ranges from 75 yards to 350 yards. The trajectory is about the same as a 30-06 at 2700 FPS, a load I used for a long time so am familiar with.
I worked up a handload for that rifle using Remington brass, Winchester WLR primers, 60.4 gr. of Re15 under the 225 gr. Barnes TSX bullet for 2710 FPS. It's a very accurate load but I strongly suggest one start at least two grains less and work up. It's fine in my Mauser but will lock up the bolt on my Remington M700 Classic. That load will penetrate an elk from exhaust pipe tp to fuel intake without any problem I haven't recover one of those bullets yet and based on past history probably never will. As long as I stick with that TSX bullet, I see no need for anything heavier.
I don't think the recoil is especially brutal. Lots of times recoil hurts because the rifle doesn't fit the shooter all that well. My M700 and Ruger M77 kick a bit harder than the Mauser but probably because they're a bit lighter in weight.
If I were to have to live with just one rifle the rest of my days, it would be that .35 Whelen Mauser, no questions asked.
Paul B.
I worked up a handload for that rifle using Remington brass, Winchester WLR primers, 60.4 gr. of Re15 under the 225 gr. Barnes TSX bullet for 2710 FPS. It's a very accurate load but I strongly suggest one start at least two grains less and work up. It's fine in my Mauser but will lock up the bolt on my Remington M700 Classic. That load will penetrate an elk from exhaust pipe tp to fuel intake without any problem I haven't recover one of those bullets yet and based on past history probably never will. As long as I stick with that TSX bullet, I see no need for anything heavier.
I don't think the recoil is especially brutal. Lots of times recoil hurts because the rifle doesn't fit the shooter all that well. My M700 and Ruger M77 kick a bit harder than the Mauser but probably because they're a bit lighter in weight.
If I were to have to live with just one rifle the rest of my days, it would be that .35 Whelen Mauser, no questions asked.
Paul B.