I guess I'd be more in the younger crowd than the older crowd, though it's getting to the point that I have to think about it....
I started in handguns circa 1999 with a Pietta replica Remington 1858 as a backup for muzzleloader hunting (yes, I'm the oddball who used a muzzleloader during regular firearms season starting at age 15...I could afford a more accurate ML than slug gun). A fun gun but a real PIA to reload and a major PIA to clean, so it saw little range use.
I seem to alternate...get a Glock 23 in 2005 for CCW, then a Taurus 85 in 2008, then a Glock 26 in 2010. Also a Taurus Ti Tracker 41Mag, another Taurus 85, and a Ruger Mark III Hunter. Inherited an 80 yr old SW 38.
I enjoy shooting them all, I don't understand why people have to pick camps and belittle the other.
Lately I have been on a bigbore handgun kick, picking up a SW 329PD and a 45 Colt conversion cylinder for the 1858. Boy is that 1858 a fun gun now! The major draws to revolvers for me right now is a) they tend to have more power and do more with reactive targets, and b) my personal range is grass so it is easier to collect brass to reload by dumping it out in my hand versus crawling through the grass looking for it.
I'm not sure which handgun I want next...either a SW 629 Classic 5" or a Kimber Eclipse Custom II in 10mm Auto....