Mehavey said:
Unfortunately, oil has to get underneath the water if it's going to displace it.
Two inches or 2 molecules, it still has to get underneath it.
You are testing the wrong displacement mechanism. So is FITASC's linked article's author. One mechanism involves displacing water from a puddle or container, while another displaces water from a metal surface. The puddle displacement can be done by any liquid denser than water because you are testing which liquid is more strongly pulled down by gravity. The other mechanism is displacing water from the surface of a piece of steel, where you are testing which liquid enjoys greater molecular attraction to the steel.
The latter mechanism is what is useful to a gun owner; not whether it floats or sinks in water. The way to test for water displacing of the latter sort is as follows:
Take a tuft of fine steel wool and soak it in a solvent until all the protective oil is gone from its surface. Let it dry. Tie a string around it so it may be suspended from a stick laid across the lip of your martini glass. Tie it to such a stick. Fill one glass with water and suspend the tuft in it until it soaks up the water. Fill another glass with the water displacing candidate. Move the water-soaked tuft (you can shake excess water off on the way over) to suspend it in the glass with the water displacing candidate and then wait a day. If the water comes out and settles in beads on the bottom of the glass, it has been displaced from the steel wool.
That latter type is the kind of displacing action the gun owner needs. Once it has been accomplished on something, I usually wash off the displacing oil with a rust-inhibiting oil like LPS-2 or apply Boeshield T9 or RIG to the surface for rust resistance, assuming that’s needed, or a 100% synthetic gun oil if I don't need rust resistance. I am, alas, another person who has seen WD-40 get tacky and found dust sticking to it after something coated with is has sat out for a year or two.
From the WD-40 web site's FAQ:
"Use WD-40 Specialist Dirt & Dust Resistant Dry Lube PTFE Spray when you need a lubricant that will keep things clean; its non-sticky formula won't attract dust or leave oily residue."
I assume the fact they identified the need for such a product means they've noticed what I described can happen.