Open Carry culture

I find it humerous how many people who "never" OC are suddenly experts on how bad it is.

If you can't OC, fine. Part of being a law abiding gun owner is being law abiding.

If you live in states that allow OC, and choose not to, fine.

If you are saying that you haven't seen ANY stong arguments about OC, then you obviously are waiting to be spoonfed. The search bar is your friend. Google is your friend. But most anti-OCers don't fall into this catagory.

Most people who think OC is a bad "tactical" decison because they weight one hypothetical (the element of surprise) higher than another hypothetical(the deterrence of a visible firearm), and that's fine.

I do love the OC bashers who like OC laws because it lets them print and get away with it...kinda defeats the argument....
 
I do love the OC bashers who like OC laws because it lets them print and get away with it...kinda defeats the argument....
Click to expand...
That's not how it works in my state and I'm pretty sure that's not how it works in most other states that allow both: If you're carrying concealed then you're carrying concealed; you aren't supposed to print and you can't just reveal your weapon and start open carrying.
 
Open carry at 7 11

I Rolled into 7 11 with my pistol on my hip. ruger 9 mil. Nothing happened. In addition, there is plenty of ammo here at cabelas in reno. i picked up 5 boxes of 9mm this weekend. no worries mate...the bs is over...
 
Theo, I know that's not how it's supposed to work, but read through this thread and others like it and you see that unfortunately that is often the mindset.

Tucker 1371 said:
I wear a small shirt and carry a full size 1911 so I'm usually printing just a little bit, I don't worry about it since OC is legal here.
Click to expand...

I know this isn't the first time I have seen this sentiment, and I am sure it isn't your first either.

ETA: That said, I don't think people should be charged with brandishing a weapon because their shirt got caught, and if an OC law can help prevent that, I'm a happy camper.
 
I don't want anyone to know I'm carrying. I'm never sure if it's an obvious deterrent or makes me a bigger target. When I see someone with a gun on their belt, I can't keep but looking at them and making a mental note of their movements.

Also, it depends on the state, but some cops are very anti OC and I'd really hate to get harassed by some activist trying to make an example of me.

...to be fair, there are morons out there that intentionally bait cops to get a youtube video out of it.
 
I live in Arizona. You can CC or OC without a permit. It's pretty common to see people OCing. When I first got here, it was strange (because I almost never saw it before) but now, it's pretty normal. I typically don't OC, except to and from the range. The few times I've OC'd in public I've never had anything more than a strange look from someone who thought a non-cop displaying a gun was strange.

Having said that, I have no problem with OCing in general. I have a problem with OCing to try to prove a political point. It doesn't help. It doesn't get people more "used" to seeing it. If anything it hurts. One only needs to look at California and the closing of the "Open Carry" loophole to understand this. A few years ago, you could open carry a handgun, as long as it was unloaded. So people started doing it a bunch to make a political statement, essentially challenging the government of California. So what did they do? They made even that illegal.
 
I think it's more complicated than that. I think in Califonia's case the temperature of the water was clear, and OC activism was a poor choice. However,this may not be so in other locations. The gambit being, it's tough to predict what the politicians will do in your state.

Here, Nevada, things went the opposite way, there was no law governing OC, there were a few publicized OC incidents, there are still no laws governing OC(limited exceptions being anywhere federal law applies and the secure areas of airports), and municipal governments for the most part have been brought into compliance with state preemption, and therefor no governance of OC. Now the municipalities and governmental organizations that attempted to use the no CC signage to enforce no OC no longer do so, with one exception, LVMPD(and I believe some of the other LEAs). Additionally, as far as I know, people no longer get harassed.

I think the two major differences, is here the state lawmakers weren't likely to change their preemption law, and aside from people going out an OC'ing with the purpose of being noticed, many people wrote letters and similar actions pointing out the violation of state law and misuse of the no CC signage in an attempt to justify prohibition of OC at public facilities.

ETA: Clarification, LVMPD does not harass OC'ers, however they do still use the no CC/Firearms signage at their facilities and will not allow people to OC on the premises, which runs contrary to state law.
 
When I'm in Florida there's no choice in the matter because it's not allowed.

At my home in Georgia, which is in the mountains, I do OC in town. It's a non event when I do.
 
That's not how it works in my state and I'm pretty sure that's not how it works in most other states that allow both: If you're carrying concealed then you're carrying concealed; you aren't supposed to print and you can't just reveal your weapon and start open carrying.
Click to expand...

Actually, in AZ that would work just fine, as both are covered under Constitutional Carry. Accidentally exposed your sidearm? No big deal.
 
I have never OC'ed, because in Chicago you can't. Hell, we can't even carry concealed... YET! I have no problems with OC and encourage it. It's a right we should have in every state, and the more people that do it the more accepted it will become.

Concerning the ammo shortage... I was at Cabela's in Hoffman Estates, IL recently and they were pretty well stocked. Picked up some .308 and was tempted to buy a bunch of 7.62x39 and 54r i knew I didn't need. Have you seen the guys on armslist trying to dump all that ammo they hoarded? Heh...
 
My shooting buddy was stopped and had his ID and the serial # on his 1911 ran and the cop treated him like a felon the whole time.
Click to expand...

Most people have forgotten that the expression of the constitutionally protected right cannot be a crime. We have allowed too much blur to occur in the law over the past 75 years or so.

This is beyond the officer's authority in Virginia because you are not committing a crime by exercising a right under Section 13 of the constitution of the Commonwealth of Virginia. Possession is ownership here and there is no cause for them to check the gun under some notion of "checking to see if it is not stolen".

I have a problem with OCing to try to prove a political point. It doesn't help.
Click to expand...

Citation?

VCDL carries at the capitol building all the time for the apparently rare occasion that people engage in several rights simultaneously. They know we're carrying and they understand that our intent is to not do them harm. They understand our political point and we're reminding them that we are not paychecks to be taxed and used at their leisure.
 
Its up to the individual what way they carry legally. Personally I don't see the point of advertising you are carrying a firearm. If someone is determined to carry out a attack it would make sense to me to take out the person carrying a firearm first.
 
Personally, I don't care if people carry openly or concealed. Open carry is more interesting because then I can check out other people's carry guns when I'm standing in line, bored. Open carry can also be an idiot magnet - do you really want folks checking out your gun while you are standing in line at Walmart? Or some con artist figuring out how to distract you so he, or an accomplice can lift that pretty BBQ gun out of your holster?
 
Theohazard said:
That's not how it works in my state and I'm pretty sure that's not how it works in most other states that allow both: If you're carrying concealed then you're carrying concealed; you aren't supposed to print and you can't just reveal your weapon and start open carrying.
Click to expand...
In a state that allows both, why can't you go from one to the other? I know you're wrong about "most" states, and I suspect you're wrong abut your state.

Let's use Pennsylvania as an example, since I'm familiar with PA. Open carry is legal with no permit (except in Philadelphia). Concealed carry is legal with a permit. There have been incidents where cops have attempted to tell people that they "can't" open carry because they have a concealed carry permit (which is actually incorrect terminology in PA) so they MUST carry concealed. Those cops get slapped down pretty hard.

Think about the logic. Two people walking down the street. Both are open carrying. One has a concealed carry permit, the other does not. By your logic, the person with the permit is breaking the law but the other is not. That makes no sense whatsoever.

So your point must be that I can't "change state"? Why not? I start out on a cool morning, so I wear a windbreaker and my sidearm is covered. I'm carrying concealed. Later, the sun is out and the day warms up considerably, so I remove the windbreaker and I'm now open carrying. Do you seriously think that the laws of any state prohibit that? Why would it be illegal for me to shift into open carry mode if it's completely legal for me to open carry from the moment I step out my front door?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
How ironic, while traveling thru Newberg Oregon yesterday I stopped for gas. A truck pulled up for gas and the passenger that got out to buy a snack in the store was OCing.... my observations, nobody cared or noticed. Based on his demeanor, not only was there nothing to worry about but he seemed very friendly (Newberg is a small town IMO).

Admittingly, Im not up to speed on OC laws in Oregon because I never considered it in any city limit. But I suspect that with a CHL its legal.... (pretty much would end the printing debate) and could be convienient at times....
 
Aquila Blanca:

I think you misunderstand me. I'm just saying that you can't be carrying concealed, then all of a sudden pull back your shirt to expose your weapon.

The law in my state (Washington), as I understand it, is as follows: You can't be carrying concealed and then decide, in full public view, to shift to open carry. When you're carrying concealed in public you're supposed to do just that; carry concealed. If you want to switch to open carry you need to do so in a private setting.

If you have a permit and want to carry concealed, then carry concealed. If you want to open carry, then open carry. You just can't switch from one to the other while in public. That is what I'm saying and that is my understanding of Washington law. However, I may be wrong.

I know the guy who literally wrote the book on Washington carry laws, maybe on Monday I'll shoot him an email. If I'm wrong about this I want to be corrected as soon as possible.
 
Hi, I'm new to the forum, but not other forums or guns. As others have said in AZ carrying guns for the most part is a non-event. Unless you are acting weird or otherwise attracting interest the PD will not bother you. If some idiot calls 911 with a "man with gun" report, the PD will likely not respond without other evidence of a crime.

Lately I've been actively looking at people to see if they are printing or carrying, so far this week I haven't seen anyone. Either everyone is carrying LCP's or they are unarmed. I suspect a lot more women than you realize have a gun in their purse, because they can.

But most open carry people who I have noticed in the past seem to fall into several categories.

There is the California visitor who is exercising his rights in a free state, because he can. That would be the one at WalMart with a shoulder holster worn OUTSIDE his jacket. LOL

Then there is the desert rat, who carries a six shooter because they are in and out of town and might need to shoot a rattlesnake, boar or bear. They usually drive a dusty pickup and wear worn leather cowboy boots (not polished alligator like the California cowboys).

There is the border resident who may well be carrying an AR 15 and a 1911 because their life may depend on it.

There is the retired geezer who is just tired of taking crap and if you are a gang banger or wannabe you'd best keep your distance because they won't hesitate to defend themselves.

There is the occasional gun rights person who carries to make a point, and my hat is off to them.

Finally there is the occasional business person who OC's coming and going or at their business.

Everyone else pretty much seems to carry concealed unless they are hiking or hunting.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Theohazard said:
I think you misunderstand me. I'm just saying that you can't be carrying concealed, then all of a sudden pull back your shirt to expose your weapon.

The law in my state (Washington), as I understand it, is as follows: You can't be carrying concealed and then decide, in full public view, to shift to open carry. When you're carrying concealed in public you're supposed to do just that; carry concealed. If you want to switch to open carry you need to do so in a private setting.
Click to expand...
Please cite the Washington state law that says this. I didn't misunderstand you, I just think your understanding is incorrect. I know your understanding is not correct for "most other states that allow both."

If this interpretation is something that developed out of case law rather than statute, please cite the case(s).

I suspect what you are thinking of is a case somewhere, some time in which someone pulled back their cover garment in order to display a sidearm in a threatening manner. I would agree that's illegal (unless done in response to an assault or threatened assault), but I find it difficult to believe that in Washington if the day turns warm I'm supposed to make like Superman and find a telephone booth before I'm allowed to remove my jacket because I'm getting hot.
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top