Is the Smith 340PD that special?

Ever try to draw from an ankle holster?

No I have never been in a real situation where I needed to draw from an ankle holster. Got any advice?

My 340pd is my least fired gun and I probably wouldn't buy it again but I like the fact that it can be worn all day and forgotten about because it's so light. I follow the advice of fellow owners and never sell any guns so I'm happy to have it in my collection.

Firing it is hard on the hands but not too bad if you use lighter 38 loads for practice
 
Ankle holsters CAN be bad. Google ankle holster varicose veins.

I like neat things and have done the j-frame thing. However, 8rnds in the LCP is just a smaller package in the pocket. (8 stock mag with Magguts springs)
 
Definitely increased the size a little, but these Pachmayr G10 grips on my LCR fill my hand better, definitely allowing for much better control and follow up shots. With that said, haven’t shot anything but 130gr .38 Special +P Ranger out of it so far.

04976245ba5f04304ce24a0e211b90c0.jpg
 
Let us know how those g10 grips work out for some mid range .357 loads. I found that the rubber hogue grips with the cushion was the most comfortable.
 
I had a 360 PD. I shot it alot with magnums. It went back to Smith twice for new frames. They are not designed to eat a diet of magnums.

I laugh at at all the big tough guys that cry about shooting a light magnum. Yup it stings, but it stings more on the other end.

The are not finnicky at all, unless you are talking about bullet pull.
 
USELESS ankle holsters

"No I have never been in a real situation where I needed to draw from an ankle holster. Got any advice?"

An ankle holster is useless unless your attacker will stop long enough for you to tie your shoes or kiss your ass good-bye!!!

T.
 
I don't use an ankle holster but there are some cases where it could be helpful. For instance, you might be seated in such a way where it beats some version of belt carry. You might be in a scuffle such that you can get a hand down to your ankle. Heck, you might even be seated, kneeling, crouched, etc. in some kind of robbery or hostage situation. These events are rare but could happen. It's just that they are arguably more rare than the set of cases in which more common carry positions are more helpful.
 
Ankle holster, no thanks... Maybe to carry a 3rd pistol. I had a friend that was ambushed, his only gun was a J frame in an ankle holster. He was shot 3 times before he could get to his gun.
 
There isn't a holster that can prevent someone from getting the drop on you.

Nevertheless, I can see drawing from an ankle holster not working for some people. For others, with good technique, it can be very fast. The fastest technique is to bring the leg up and the hand down at the same time. A big advantage is the holster is pointed in the direction of the target before the gun is even drawn. I am totally convinced from a timer beep to muzzle on target it is as fast as any other technique where a concealment garment must be swept.

Of course, reality is not always like practice. In some circumstances, a person would drop or take cover or concealment before they attempt to draw. Getting down before you draw is slower to get the muzzle on target, but a person may do it anyway, because drawing isn't the only thing we think about. There are some circumstances where ankles are inaccessible. One person wrote about needing to draw when being pressed in a large crowd. But ankle holsters are easier for some to reach when seated in a car compared to carry options where one is sitting on the gun.

With ankle carry it is so easy to achieve concealment without printing even when you're wearing nothing more than a shirt and pants and you can even tuck the shirt in. Quick-draw isn't the only concern, especially for those who carry to "have and not need rather than need and not have." It is a contingency, and compromises are made, those associated with ankle carry being the least of several others.
 
The fastest technique is to bring the leg up and the hand down at the same time. A big advantage is the holster is pointed

Are you doing a Rockette kick towards your enemy? I cannot see how this could work any other way unless you are lying on your back???

Like has been said ankle holsters are for backup or super discrete carry. Not every conceivable situation puts you as the primary ambushee so to speak yet you could still be involved.
 
I absolutely HATE this statement. Its not about feeling the recoil, its about it interfering with your willingness and ability to practice enough with the gun to be proficient in its use under stress.

I have one of the Titanium framed 38spl guns. It is unpleasant thru the first cylinder. By cylinder #3... im done. Thats only 15 rounds. Not nearly enough to ingrain the skills needed to be efficient with these hard to shoot guns.

Ive always viewed the J frames as expert guns. Like, you REALLY have to know what youre doing to shoot them well. These ultra-light versions are the tip of that spear



The problem is in dealing with the autonomic nervous system. If you practice with an abusing handgun, you’ll learn to flinch. And just like someone who would get slapped everyday, you’ll still flinch when pulling the trigger. It’s unconscious reflexes.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Last edited:
I have shot S&W scandium J-frames with .38spl loads such as 130gr FMJ and 158gr in +P and std pressure. Not fun. I would think .357 would be even more unfun. For those that can, God bless you.

I would think that the S&W scandium alloy J-frames would be about perfect to mate with the old 148gr HBWC such as the Federal Gold Match. My wife shoots those out of a slightly heavier alloy revolver (17oz) and the recoil is manageable enough for her to get in some practice. I generally prefer the FBI load or sportier analogs from Buff Bore or Underwood, but the target wadcutter keeps calling my name.

And for the OP, I am not sure if he is kidding writing about the "rare Gen 1 Glock 17." Glocks are competent quality shooting appliances, but none of them are noteworthy. Might as well talk about that "rare Toyota Camry 4-cyl."
 
And for the OP, I am not sure if he is kidding writing about the "rare Gen 1 Glock 17." Glocks are competent quality shooting appliances, but none of them are noteworthy. Might as well talk about that "rare Toyota Camry 4-cyl."

Well, I sold that 1st gen for much more than the newest latest models, so yes, some people are collecting them.

Remember how common place Volkswagons were? We were not wealthy, so that's all we drove in the old days. But you see how much a Kombi van is going for these days. I would be a millionaire if I had kept all my VW's from the past!

Anyways, I did pass on that 340PD beause it didn't do anything that my LCR could.
 
Back
Top