No option for "other"?
These threads are tough because I have to make an EXTREME compromise between plinkability, carry, and a hunting/magnum pistol.
Usually I pick something highly configurable even though I wouldn't likely purchase one otherwise. Something like an EAA Witness or TC Encore.
Today's choice that I wouldn't buy otherwise is the Sig P320. The trigger is pretty good, and I have my pick of calibers, frame sizes, and slide lengths. Even though a conversion kit costs as much as a whole new gun, it matters less if it's the only pistol I can own.
This way, I could have a LONG, fat, large, heavy and uninteresting subcompact 9mm for carry, a full sized 9mm for plinking, and a full sized .357 Sig (sigh) to almost fill out the magnum side.