Like many others, hard to pick just one.
Past?
- A Ruger Single Six 5.5" in .32 Mag ca. 1984. Need that one back.
Current?
- Rare/non-catalogued "4th gen" (late 3rd) Colt SAA 5.5" in .44 Special.
- Honorable mention. Pre-Lock S&W 65LS (Lady Smith), various Ruger Vaquero .44 Mags, various Ruger .32 Mag "Vaquerito" Single Sixes.
Prospective/wish list?
- Ruger BH/Flattop .44 Special,
- Dan Wesson 1911 "VBOB"(Valor Bobtail) .45 or similar but pricier: Ed Brown Special Forces Bobtail .45.
If I had to pick from all of above for an "only 1 gun allowed" scenario?
- Brain driven: 65 Lady Smith. Choice #1 of current/actual owned
- Visceral/heart driven: Colt SAA .44 Sp and #2 choice among actual owned
- Brain + heart and the winner (but close): Ruger .44 Sp BH/Flattop don't currently have.
- These three could switch (or the above 1911) on any given day!