Define Loaded Gun

Status
Not open for further replies.
B

BarryLee

New member
Ok, had a friendly disagreement with someone concerning a sign at a local range and wanted a little feedback. A local indoor range has sign posted that reads, “No Loaded Guns or Magazines”.

I told the guy behind the counter that I understood the ban on loaded guns, but didn’t understand the issue with loaded magazines. He basically said that if the magazine was loaded and in the gun someone might chamber a round presenting a safety issue. I responded that a loaded magazine in a gun was actually a loaded gun. However, he disagreed and said a loaded magazine was simply that and that the gun itself wasn’t actually loaded until a round was chambered.

So, I understand this isn’t really a big deal, but just curious what others might think.
 
I agree with the range counter person, a loaded magazine doesn't load the gun until a round is chambered.
 
Good question--I personally consider any cartridge within a firearm in any manner constitutes a loaded weapon (and for safety's sake assume all weapons are loaded until proven otherwise). If I had to guess--they probably have that rule cause they want to keep people from fooling with their magazines while the range is cold--reducing the probability of someone loading the magazine and having an AD or otherwise. I have seen some amazingly stupid things on a fairly regular basis at public ranges and marvel that more people are not killed at them.
 
I usually call a gun with a loaded magazine in it loaded and one with a loaded magazine and a round in the chamber I usually call loaded with one in the chamber.
 
Just to confuse the issue, in New York state a pistol in a car with ammunition nearby is considered loaded. It's illegal to leave a loaded gun in a car while you go to run an errand, etc.

Back to the point, I consider a gun with a loaded magazine as loaded.
 
BarryLee, I agree. Here's why.

Let's look at the opposite term. There's loaded, and *unloaded.

I think less people would be willing to say that a pistol with a mag in is completely unloaded.
"Did you unload the gun? - Yep it still has 15 rounds in it though"

At an IDPA match, after the shooter is done the command is "Unload and show clear" and the chamber is visually checked. Mag is dropped, round is ejected and slide locked back. How much of that is from the "unload" and how much is from "clear"? I suppose we could explore the subtleties between the two... but I don't feel like it.

Side note. Don't you love it when the media always gasps, "he had a *loaded* gun!!!" - silly rabbit, guns are always presumed loaded, you shouldn't be surprised when it's confirmed.
 
The actual interpretation of the law varies by state. Personally, if there isn't a round in the chamber I don't consider it loaded. That is far different from treating every gun as if it is loaded. That is a given.
 
"I usually call a gun with a loaded magazine in it loaded and one with a loaded magazine and a round in the chamber I usually call loaded with one in the chamber."
Yup.
 
The definition can vary a bit, depending on where you are and what you
are doing.

My wife and I participate in USPSA handgun competitions. From the rulebook:


Loaded Firearm ................A firearm having a live round, empty case or dummy round in the chamber or cylinder, or having a live or dummy round in a magazine inserted in the firearm.

We live and carry in Oregon. One definition from Oregon statute:


166.360 Definitions for ORS 166.360 to 166.380. As used in ORS 166.360 to 166.380, unless the context requires otherwise:

(3) “Loaded firearm” means:
(a) A breech-loading firearm in which there is an unexpended cartridge or shell in or attached to the firearm including but not limited to, in a chamber, magazine or clip which is attached to the firearm.
 
I would call a loaded gun one with ammunition in it, even if not in the chamber. Is a SAA Colt considered not loaded with 5 rounds in the cylinder?
 
There is a difference between "loaded" and "in battery", that's where we're losing the nuance. When I load a magazine, and load that magazine into my weapon, that weapon is now loaded.

When I retract the slide and chamber a round, now it's in battery. It's still loaded, too.
 
In general usage, "loaded" means rounds in the gun. One should always assume, for safety, there could be a round in the chamber. Until the introduction of modern repeaters, "loaded" ALWAYS meant round in the chamber.

"Unload" means to remove all ammunition from the gun.

"Clear" means to remove the round from the chamber. "Show clear" means gun open, empty, so visual inspection shows the clear chamber.

"Loaded" in legal terms, however means different things, depending on where you are. The laws vary more than a bit, and what is perfectly legal one place is an offence on the other side of the political (state, usually) line.

Some places, rounds in the gun, but none in the chamber is still legally loaded.
Another place, it is not. Another place, rounds in a magazine NOT IN THE GUN, but in the same compartment as the gun (passenger or trunk) constitutes loaded, legally. Another place it does not, but only if the gun and ammo are in separate locked containers...

Some state define it by access. IF you have access to both the gun and the ammo the gun is considered loaded, even when there are no rounds in it. (ex: you, driving, empty gun in glove box, ammo in back seat, its "loaded, under the letter of the law. IF the ammo, OR the gun, (or you) were in the trunk, under that law, the gun would not be considered loaded.

AND, in some places, a loaded gun is allowed, but only ON your person.

There are about as many variations as there are states (or so it seems), and you BEST KNOW the laws in each state you enter, BEFORE you get there.
 
I believe many states legally define loaded to mean it takes one action (IE pulling the trigger) to fire a round. A magazine in the well would require at least 2 actions (racking the slide, pulling the trigger) to fire. The way they look at revolvers just goes to show how many people writing firearm laws know nothing about firearms. I have seen at least 2 states with the above definition refer to a DA only revolver as loaded if the cylinder under the hammer or the cylinder adjacent to it has a round in the chamber. To me requiring a single action would mean that the cylinder where the hammer is could have a round while the next could not. evidently people think you can (under normal operation) fire a DA only with out rotating the cylinders.
 
I personally consider any cartridge within a firearm in any manner constitutes a loaded weapon (and for safety's sake assume all weapons are loaded until proven otherwise)
Click to expand...
I agree. Shoot a competition match and at the end of the stage you will be instructed "if finished UNLOAD and SHOW CLEAR.
To me it is stating that with the magazine in the gun the gun is loaded.
 
I think there are three levels of readiness, and they're not the same for all guns.
For instance, an auto pistol with a loaded mag in the well, but no round in the chamber, is not loaded, but it's not unloaded, either.
A revolver with an empty chamber under the hammer is loaded, since pulling the trigger (DA), or cocking and pulling the trigger (SA) will fire the gun.
In IDPA competition, the gun is considered loaded if there's ammo in the magazine or a round is in the chamber, but it's not considered unloaded until it's been cleared of all ammo.
Under some conditions, the gun is considered loaded if the gun has malfunctioned and is out of battery, but that's a procedural issue, and not a matter of safety.
 
I don't think it really matters. You questioned it, they answered it, that's what it means there. Communicatin was established.

As for legal definition, that will vary greatly state by state, and state regulations and definitions are not required to reflect common sense or reality in any way so it's whatever THEY say it is.


Ohio's definition of "loaded gun" as it pertains to a vehicle was a magazine or a speed loader with rounds in ithem. I believe they recently changed or were in the process of changing that.
 
I don't think it really matters. You questioned it, they answered it, that's what it means there. Communicatin was established.
Click to expand...

I agree to a certain extent, but what concerned me is that I generally load a little over 100 rounds in various magazines before I go to the range. So, I end up carrying in several “loaded magazines” and was curious if that was a problem for the range and why. The guy actually told me that what I was doing was ok as long as they weren’t in a gun. Again, I realize this isn’t really a big deal, but just curious what you folks thought.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top