I never found carrying the full-size guns to be much of a problem. I carried Government Model and Commander 1911's probably more than anything else in my life, and did so on a daily basis.
Even these days with 9mm, I carry a Glock 17 daily, and often a Glock 26 along with it. I base what I carry on what I shoot best with, not what I find easier to carry.
I too have a 1917 S&W, and it is pretty big, but I dont think Id Ive to much trouble with it if I used a proper holster. The larger revolvers are generally more of a pain to hide than the autos though. Ive carried 4" K and N frame Smiths for a time back in the 70's, and while its still very doable, the Colt Government Model, was always a bit easier.
Even these days with 9mm, I carry a Glock 17 daily, and often a Glock 26 along with it. I base what I carry on what I shoot best with, not what I find easier to carry.
I too have a 1917 S&W, and it is pretty big, but I dont think Id Ive to much trouble with it if I used a proper holster. The larger revolvers are generally more of a pain to hide than the autos though. Ive carried 4" K and N frame Smiths for a time back in the 70's, and while its still very doable, the Colt Government Model, was always a bit easier.