Best deal on a used handgun? Hmmm...
Back in early 2007, I wandered into the local Gander Molehill and noticed they were having a sale on milsurp "arsenal refinished" Walther P1 pistols. I'd always been interested in that gun, and the $269 sale price was just too enticing, so I decided on impulse to pick one up.
The salesman brought out four P1s from the storeroom. Three of them had unacceptable (to me) levels of cosmetic wear, but the fourth one looked absolutely pristine and apparently unfired. I left with that particular P1.
That was Surprise #1. After detail-stripping the gun and honing the internals a bit to improve the trigger pull, I brought it to the range for the first time, and was treated to Surprise #2. I had read that these milsurp P1s were merely "rack grade" service handguns with a commensurately adequate level of accuracy... and was therefore more than mildly surprised to discover that this particular P1 was able to consistently hold a sub-3" group at 25 yards, shooting my subsonic target handloads. The non-adjustable sights were even right on target at that distance, with the POI equal to the POA. Unbelievable.
A target-grade handgun for under $300. Color me impressed! At this point, I was so smitten with the P1 that I decided to do the most natural thing: get another one. So back to Gander I went a few days later, when they had dropped the price of the P1 further to $239! I went through the same motions of having the saleperson bring out several P1s from the storeroom. Again, most were cosmetically blemished, but among them was one that was in mint, unfired condition. And again, that one followed me home where it was oiled up, sealed in a plastic bag, placed in a foam-lined case, and stored in the gun safe where it remains to this day.
Here's an image of the first P1, which I still enjoy shooting on a regular basis:
The other one gets taken out of the safe one or twice a year to be
fondled inspected and cleaned/reoiled as necessary.