Well said.It's call a pissing match and adds nothing to the conversation.
Almost nobody goes to their local sporting goods store with the intention of buying an elk rifle and comes home with a 7-08.....period.
I bought my first 7-08 in 1993, I've had 5 of them, still have 2, it's the most dependable deer cartridge I've ever used, one of the best silhouette cartridges and a pretty good hunter bench rest cartridge.
It's to weak of a cartridge for long shots at bull elk.
Double K said:So mister I do everything down to the letter of the law how would you have handled the situation, try and make it believable.
I did a search on who you are, your just a pup! I'll cut you some slack because of your youth, after you've killed a couple hundred big game animals you'll lighten up a little.
Hint for this coming big game season, the only way you'll ever kill big bucks and bulls is by stop shooting those 2-3 old ones.
NHSHOOTER said:I will be bumping up my arsenal to a more acceptable cartridge for elk and keep the ole' 7-08 for deer (which it does very well on)..I am leaning towards the 300 win mag.
That's a better response than I expected, you do a good job talking the talk but do you walk the walk, no way to tell on a forum.All I can say Double K is you had a choice to make, and you made it. You killed a buck without a license, plain and simple. If you had gotten caught you would have had to face the punishment for illegally shooting a deer. You just admitted on a public forum to taking the easy way out, then have tried to back track out using ethics and morals.
If you're hunting near or on private property it's a good think to get to know your neighbors. You can usually work out some sort of compromise before season in case something like a wounded animal crossing property lines (fences) happens. If you can't work out a compromise then you might have to give the local GW a call to come out and help you recover a animal. If neighbor is a real problem case, then it's probably best not to shoot game real close to that property line.
The rest I don't even feel the need to touch on.
I have to agree. My son shot a deer and I knew it would be a track it forever type deal. .223, and not ideal shot placement. Just as it almost made it to the wood line, I layed it down with .257 Roy. He told everybody he killed it. Etc. Etc. The important thing was that I tagged it. I just was not in mood to track for hours in saw briars.Double K recommend magnums for elk if like, I have no problem with that. There never was a debate IMO to lose. You just feel that your opinion matters more than anyone else on this subject, so of course you would say I was never winning the debate.
Colorado is not "perfectly fine" with you shooting game you don't have a license for wounded or not. Your wife would have had to make a reasonable attempt to recover her buck had it made it over the fence onto someone else's private property. You shooting it without a license for it is not a "reasonable attempt" by any definition. Nor is it's "perfectly fine" in other states going to be a winning defense.
What you did was considered party hunting at a minimum, it could have been considered poaching as charges often get stacked. Also depending on the points could of had you violating the Sampson Law. All of which could if convicted could have cost you several thousands in fines and lost hunting privileges in most of the U.S. for a few years. So if you feel that strongly what you did was morally/ethically right violating Colorado game laws, I say do what you can afford.