Back to the OP's original post. I think the .338 WinMag is the better all around caliber between the two when considering reloading, or commercial ammo availability and the capability of the cartridge. Mine is a BAR with a Pachmayr Decelerator. Is there recoil... yup, but not that bad. I have the ability to hunt any medium to large game in the lower 48 and with the right load any dangerous game in North America.