Well done, and I'm glad you found the comvination that works for you!
My criteria are usually more simple.
1. Is it reliable
2. Do I shoot it well
3. Does it carry OK.
I tend to actually use a pair, one full/duty size to carry when I can and one compact when I need more concealment (similar to your theory), thre full size also pulls nightstand duty.
Currently it is s full size 1911 and a 3" compact 1911.
Also in the past were a Glock 17/26 pair and a Glock 30/21 pair.
My weekly range time is primarily the carry platform to keep muscle memory current.
My criteria are usually more simple.
1. Is it reliable
2. Do I shoot it well
3. Does it carry OK.
I tend to actually use a pair, one full/duty size to carry when I can and one compact when I need more concealment (similar to your theory), thre full size also pulls nightstand duty.
Currently it is s full size 1911 and a 3" compact 1911.
Also in the past were a Glock 17/26 pair and a Glock 30/21 pair.
My weekly range time is primarily the carry platform to keep muscle memory current.