Why doesnt S&W make Aluminum K/L Frames!

My guess is fatigue life. Aluminum has a finite fatigue life. Yes, the J frames have aluminum frames but a full sized revolver would be fired much more often and S&W would be responding to all sorts of reports of cracked aluminum frames.

That is my guess.
 
Magnum Wheel, I have one of those also and mine is an L-frame. You might want to check your facts a little closer.

Dave
 
I think a better option for Smith would be to expand the J-frame somewhat like Taurus did and add a 6th hole in that cylinder. It would be a Smith Detective Special of sorts. Taurus guns aren't high on my opinion list, so I didn't buy one, but the idea is neat. A 6-shot J+ frame would be my new carry gun, especially if they made a 3" with good, sturdy, adjustable sights. They could call it the JK.
 
Sorry DAVE, not intentional... can't keep all that info straight sometimes... ( still fits within the topic though ;) ) never could get a handle on the model numbers :o
 
chewie, S&W did prototype a small sixshooter comparable to Colt DS.
They did not think it would sell and scrapped them. I have seen pictures of one that escaped.
 
The 2" M12 is a joy to carry everyday, even in the pocket of khakis or Dockers. Unsurpassed K-frame action, grip options, and that 6th shot.
 
I predict Ruger will own this market with a medium-frame polymer/alloy/steel wheel gun - I call it the LSR for Light Service Revolver. What excites me about the concept is the potential cost savings over steel revolvers and the much improved potential for carry.

I'm thinking about something the size of a hammerless K-frame, barrels of 2, 3, and 4", and a weight of somewhere between 22-oz and 28-oz, depending on caliber and barrel. I'll take a 5-shot .44 Special, a 6 or 7 shot .38/.357, and a 10-shot .22 LR, for starters. Street prices under $500. Who's with me?
 
Its too bad we cant all carry the full size weapon of our choice everyday without "Big Brother" stepping in for everyones safety.

I like the feel of a full weight gun at my side, not sure if I would like Aluminum. if I am going the light route I have a full sized XDm.
 
Because aluminum is for beer cans and airplanes. Steel is for precision high strength tools that must work. I consider a handgun a tool.
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top