Why carry compact?

Will you at least fire in the air? Not to be a hero, just to be a responsible armed citizen.
Click to expand...

So...in response to a person randomly shooting behind them, you would suggest that shooting into the air is a valid option? That seems to be the opposite of responsible.
 
Random shootings happen where everyone present is the target. Not trying to inspire any ideas, But if a shooter did decidecide to elevate and shoot from a distance, he would get more victims, the mindset of going off of what has happened will affect your reaction to what could happen. Some whackjobs are very well trained. And some thugs were once soldiers, marines, and even cops! I've seen kids that can shoot very well. And how is any training, whether it be long or short shots, a waste? Even you said the longshots you took at 200yds was fun.
Click to expand...

If he's randomly shooting from a distance your best bet is duck and run. Unless your concealed carry is a Remington 30-06, you are distinctly out gunned with a mere pistol.

As noted I have no problem with people doing distance shooting for fun. But thinking you're good to trade fire at range it tactically and legally inprudent.
 
To take cover, run, escape is reasonable and when possible should be part of any good defense. Tacticians in all ages have shown that it's better avoid a fight when you can and from the distances mentioned I would choose flight over fight.

I have meet lots of over zealous gun carrying persons that really think being in a gun fight would be cool afternoon. I say let the police handle it. Would I pull my gun and fire at a bad guy attacking me hell yeah; bad guy fleeing and being shoot in the back where I live may be murder. I am confident enough with my weapon that I could stop a threat or to be clear hit what I aim at and I would pray the if in this dreaded scenario the threat would be down stopped or slowed enough for me to escape, regroup, and call for help.

To me the bad guy starts with the advavtage he knows what he came to do, and if given a chance to retreat, take cover, regroup, get more help that's my choice, yours is no doubt different.
Click to expand...

Agreed. Odds are extremly low that it will be just me-but I will be protecting a family member I value more than myself. If we can't run for whatever reason then a CC is better than me just charging the person, which would be what I would have to do if I didn't have the CC.
 
As usual, I'm late for the discussion, so I'll just put in my 2 cents for the OP: I personally only use full-size guns for CCW. To me, small guns are for BUG use only. I have no problem concealing a full-size weapon. In my case, I alternate between a Ruger P-90 .45 and another Ruger, a 4" stainless GP-100 .357 Magnum. Both disappear completely in an IWB rig underneath an un-tucked shirt. The way I see it, since fine motor skills tend to diminish under the stress of a gunfight, handling a tiny gun with correspondingly tiny controls would be pretty difficult compared to a full-sized piece. Besides, in my opinion, when it comes to certain things, like steaks, paychecks, locomotives, women, and guns..bigger is better!;)
 
Put me in the camp of only needing a gun to shoot up to 10 yards away. Any more than that and you'll need a better lawyer. I like my Kahr.
 
In the military there's a thing called fire control.
Click to expand...
The military also issues rifles for this purpose. If you think adding an inch to the barrel to your CCW pistol is going to swing the tide in your favor and all of a sudden gives you firepower superiority your thinking is probably gonna get you in trouble, your still very much outgunned against any longarm.
 
I agree with mavracer, however I'll point out that there can be exceptions to any and every rule. Case in point: The early 1990s incident involving a nut with an AK vs. a USAF Security Forces member, who was armed only with a 9mm Beretta. The aforementioned lunatic had been gleefully engaging in mass murder at a military base when he was intercepted by the SF man. From a distance of about 70 yards, the SF man used his issued M9 to cut down his rifle-armed adversary, who was actively shooting at him at the time. The good guy survived unscathed, the murderer was not so lucky.
 
your still very much outgunned against any longarm.
Click to expand...

Of course! What was that Clint said? The only reason we fight with a pistol is to get back to the rifle that we shouldn't have laid down in the first place...

So the pistol is sort of a stand in compact rifle in effect. Even a full size pistol is very very compact when compared to a rifle. So why handicap yourself with a micro pistol?

It's not about needing to shoot past 10 yds, it's about ease of effective use. It's easier to get effective hits at 10 yds or less with a bigger pistol than it is with a smaller pistol. It's easier to shoot faster with a bigger pistol than a smaller pistol.

I can shoot twice as fast with my 5" 1911 than I can with my j frame. (effectively). I'm not slamming on you snubby guys, if you can shoot fast and accurate with your snubby, wonderful! I can not. But I can shoot my 911 better with one hand fast than I can those infernal snubs with two hands.
Or so it seems to me.
 
Zincwarrior: True enough, but the point I was trying to make is that while a pistol is a pretty rotten weapon to take to a rifle fight, the handgunner can, in certain circumstances, still prevail. Besides, while it's true that the example I gave was more of an LE situation, the fact remains that the rifle-toting BG was shooting at the SF guy. So, while the SF man was, first and foremost, trying to stop a mass murderer, he was also at the same time defending himself. So, at least in one respect, this was an SD situation as well.
 
Fullsize you talk about being a good gun owner and responsible citizen, yet you talk about shooting out tires and shooting randomly in the air. Are you using magic bullets that do not fall to the ground? No offense, but I hope new gun owners who might be reading this realize what it really means to be a good gun owner and responsible citizen. Real like is not a video game. Military people use rifles to control situations. Carrying a 5" handgun instead of a 3" handgun is not putting you in SEAL mode
 
Quote:
your still very much outgunned against any longarm.

Of course! What was that Clint said? The only reason we fight with a pistol is to get back to the rifle that we shouldn't have laid down in the first place...

So the pistol is sort of a stand in compact rifle in effect. Even a full size pistol is very very compact when compared to a rifle. So why handicap yourself with a micro pistol?

It's not about needing to shoot past 10 yds, it's about ease of effective use. It's easier to get effective hits at 10 yds or less with a bigger pistol than it is with a smaller pistol. It's easier to shoot faster with a bigger pistol than a smaller pistol.

I can shoot twice as fast with my 5" 1911 than I can with my j frame. (effectively). I'm not slamming on you snubby guys, if you can shoot fast and accurate with your snubby, wonderful! I can not. But I can shoot my 911 better with one hand fast than I can those infernal snubs with two hands.
Or so it seems to me.
Click to expand...

Here's the problem.
You can't wear a full size 1911 in a dress shirt.
You can theoretically wear a full size 1911 in shorts and light T shirt in August in Texas.

If your locale and lifestyle permits you to carry a full size pistol, then excellent. For other people, conditions vary. One should carry what they can comfortably carry and confortably 24/7. That may be one pistol. It may be sveral different pistols.
 
fullsize

I am a law abiding citizen and where I live the law on CC is clear; pull and use your weapon to stop a person or persons directly engaged in attacking you, not to protect your property nor persons around you. We all know and me included we would break that law in the case of loved ones or in the case of a home invasion while your in your home.

Pulling your gun firing in the air would get my permit revoked and may bring a felony, it's not allowed here, neither can I move to act on behalf of the good of public saftey or as was stated "... a resoponsilbe gun owner..."; would I do something if I could, I don't know if I would give up my "safe" position of cover to get into the fight; if I did it would be under a very narrow circumstances.

My weapon is for my protection and I would extend that to my family, but if a bad guy wants my shiny new Silverado Z71 that I worked hard for and he got the drop on me (meaning his gun in hand pointed at me, mine still holstered) then I'm giving up the truck, they still make trucks, but my life should not end trying to out draw this bad guy. If he lowers the gun, drops his head, or is otherwise distracted where I have a second to get my gun on target, it's on, and none of that can happen from more than 10ft-15ft away.

Everytime we hear about a mass shooting we also hear least I have heard persons saying if I was there I woulda pulled my glock, my sig, whatever and did this or that, but having been on the other end of a gun barrel at close range from a car jacker, it unfolds quickly and in my case I was not carrying at the time and had I been I was seated in a car behind the wheel, not the ideal place to unholster a gun and get it on target and fire in the midst of the panic of seeing a gun pointed at me. So when persons say what they would do I just counter and say I hope you never have to find out cause you really don't know what you will do, as a gun carrier or not.
 
Respond if the law permits. Have the weapon with you that you shoot best, for me, its a fullsize handgun. To me they give you the widest range of a fughting chance. If you are already drawn on, I dont advise going out in a blaze of glory.
 
My choice for CCW was pretty easy I went for the LC9 sub comp. NYS limits a mag. to 10 shots anyway. So I went for comfort,reliability and accuracy.
My practice drills are from 5'-30' SD and 50' for target.
Chances are my SD needs will be in the 5-30ft range and in home 30ft will be a stretch.
I agree with jimbob86
 
Last edited:
So the pistol is sort of a stand in compact rifle in effect. Even a full size pistol is very very compact when compared to a rifle. So why handicap yourself with a micro pistol?
Click to expand...
Because day in and day out I've found pocket carry works best for ME.
I can shoot twice as fast with my 5" 1911 than I can with my j frame. (effectively). I'm not slamming on you snubby guys, if you can shoot fast and accurate with your snubby, wonderful! I can not. But I can shoot my 911 better with one hand fast than I can those infernal snubs with two hands.
Or so it seems to me.
Click to expand...
I shoot a snub very well,but it did take a while for me to get there. I'll also say for me there is damn little difference between a 4" and 5" barreled auto or between a 3" and 4" revolver.
 
Quote:
You can't wear a full size 1911 in a dress shirt.



False. Very false generalization.

I wear a full sized 1911 in a dress shirt easily. I can wear a Glock 21 in a dress shirt easily.
Click to expand...

A tucked in dress shirt? OK. :rolleyes:
 
I shoot a snub very well,but it did take a while for me to get there. I'll also say for me there is damn little difference between a 4" and 5" barreled auto or between a 3" and 4" revolver.
Click to expand...

Depending on the pistol I agree with you. I know one handed there is almost no difference between my M&Pc and my regular M&P. Indeed, there is only about an ounce or so difference between the two.

A short aluminum 45 might be a good bit different though-say 25 ounces vs. 35 ounces for a full size.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top