Why can't I decide?/Which gun?

I'm very conflicted with a lot of these opinions. I personally love the Glock compacts and sub-compacts. They're GREAT guns that pack a ton of firepower into their size, but the snubby .38's are reliable platforms that offer a lot of power for how big they are.

You honestly can't go wrong with either. Whichever gun you've spent time with will be a great choice for you. A snubby .38 or a sub-compact 9mm/.40 are interchangeable in my mind, but being the semi-loving guy I am, I say: get the Glock or an equivalent gun.

To me, compact 1911's won't do the same job, especially if they're .380 models (like the mustang). The capacity is lower compared to the Glock (or equivalent) and the round isn't as powerful (compared to the .380). If you go with a compact .45, you'll get more power per shot, but FAR less capacity.

Just my two cents, take it as you will.
 
Go to the gun stores and handle them all. Maybe you've already done it, but do it again. Buy the one that you think feels the nicest in your hand. Most all of us are going to name our personal favorites. Which in the long run might turn out not to be yours.
Click to expand...
Wise words.

There is no shame in buying something you "think" you like, and then later realizing that you like something else better...I've been doing exactly that for 20+ years (but a lot more frequently since I moved to a Free State and got my CHL). :)
 
Get one of each. Problem solved. :cool:

Seriously! Over time, you'll eventually acquire them all. You know you will. :D

--Wag--
 
In my case, the best CCW pistol out there is a walther PPS. Reasonably small. Very thin, a great package in either 9mm or .40 cal. Shoots better than the short barrel would lead you to believe. Can also be found in the $550-$650 range.
 
LOL

Sorry but your post is funny. I haven't read all the remarks but I'm sure every one on this board can relate. I will say that I love my Glock 23. Infact my Glock 23 is hands down my favorite pistol. However I would rather carry my wifes Glock 26 when it comes to IWB. And I would rather carry my pm9 to my wifes Glock 26 (IWB). If I have pants on there's a good chance I have my PM9 with me. There! I'm sure that solved all your problems. :D After second thought. Yes - just buy one of each. In fact, if you don't I will.
 
I have to throw one more in the mix since you seem interested in a small .45 for carry and don't mind giving up round count. Have you thought about the Glock 36? Ok, I'm done now before I spend all your money. :D
 
Glocks and XDs are good

Glocks and XDs are EXCELLENT choices...they may be out of your price range, though! But, you really can't beat them in quality, durablility, or simply all-around coolness!! :):D:cool:
 
Revolver: S&W model 60 3in barrel in .357. As close to a do it all gun I've found.

Auto: Glock-36, best .45acp I've found for CCW. Great size and weight for the.45.
 
I did consider the Glock 36, now Ruger came out with the LC9 and I'm wavering again. The 1911 guys almost had me, I will own one some day, but I'm not sure I want it as my primary carry gun. I'm still probably a couple of months away from a purchase, so I have plenty of time to change my mind a few more times (or a few more dozen times). I tend to overthink stuff like this.
 
Zombieslayer said:

"A good 1911 is the way to go, imo. If you can afford it, the Dan Wesson Vbob is a really nice carry gun. I've heard it called a poor man's Ed Brown, but poor men really can't afford a $1500 pistol, either. Springfield makes a good, affordable 1911..."

+1 If not a VBOB, then a nice, gently used model of its predecessor the Dan Wesson CBOB (Classic/commander Bobtail). Both of these use a generous helping of Ed Brown parts, including the bob'd mainspring housing. They are "bob'd" versions of the venerable 4" (4.1-4.2") Commander style, a great all around 1911 length compromise that sacrifices little in accuracy/shootability to the standard 5", while being more carryable (in this case aided by the bob'd mainspring housing/backstrap feature as well).

The new Kimber Pro Carry is this configuration as well though I note they don't credit EB MSH parts (which they may or may not use?)

Dan Wesson also has introduced a cheaper ($)--versus the VBOB-- alloy framed commander bob'd (and non-bob'd) model This is also available coated like the "black" VBOB variant. The model name escapes me.

Unless I've missed something I've found it odd that Springfield has basically ignored this very popular and useful commander market. I'd be all over a Loaded Springfield Commander. Before folks respond au contraire re officer and such models, I'm talking a bona fide steel 4.1-4.2" full-grip-size commander.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top