Actually the New Vaquero is good to 23K pressure loads (Tier 2), so not 'just' for Tier 1 loads. Just an FYI . Tier 3 (30k Ruger Only Loads) is reserved for the original Vaquero and large frame BHs as stated. I personally like the New Vaquero better as not into 'hot' loads. Plenty strong for any load that I ever will want to shoot in .45 Colt revolver.If you want to handload some hot loads, get an older Vaquero, as it is a stronger gun. If you want to stay with standard pressure loads, the New Vaquero is plenty strong enough and in some ways, it's an improved model.
Handled the BirdsHead and disagree..feels REALLY good in 'my' hand. This is a range toy, along with son's own Uberti Cattleman in 45LC, another son's S&W 686.Since it will now be a 38/357, then I highly recommend the Ruger New Vaquero, or, 2nd choice, the flat-top, Blackhawk. Bird's-head grips are for the birds. Just get the regular grips. The only question worth pondering over is which barrel length to choose.
Handled the BirdsHead and disagree..feels REALLY good in 'my' hand. This is a range toy, along with son's own Uberti Cattleman in 45LC, another son's S&W 686.
I'm liking the 3.5inch barrel..good enough for Doc Holiday, good enough for me..
Both are quality firearms with good reviews. Comes down to which do you want. What we would buy between the two is really irrelevant.