Straitshot
New member
I am considering buying a new Winchester 1873 rifle for target shooting and hunting. I am trying to decide if I should get it in .357 magnum or .45 Colt. I reload so can reload for either round. I am just not certain which round would be the most efficient for both target and hunting.
I have hunted hogs with the .45 Colt and had no problems. I once hunted deer with a .357 magnum S&W revolver and had no problems. Most of my single actions are .45 Colt but do have a Cimmarron Bisley in .357 magnum.
Just curious what you guys would suggest would be my best choice of caliber.
And to throw another thought into the equation what of the 44-40?
I have posted this question on another site so I apologize if you have seen it before.
I have hunted hogs with the .45 Colt and had no problems. I once hunted deer with a .357 magnum S&W revolver and had no problems. Most of my single actions are .45 Colt but do have a Cimmarron Bisley in .357 magnum.
Just curious what you guys would suggest would be my best choice of caliber.
And to throw another thought into the equation what of the 44-40?
I have posted this question on another site so I apologize if you have seen it before.