The Nazis were known for being under dressed for cold, wearing their dress uniforms with a trench coat. There were complaints mainly due to lack of ability of the carbine to penetrate saplings, small trees, the siding of buildings, etc., where the Garand could. This feature is what makes it desirable for home defense apps. The carbine was designed as a replacement for the 45, not the Garand, although it was used in place of an assault rifle in close quarters with some success. The M2 carbine could be fired in full auto also.