I am a new XL7 owner (30-06). I bought my rifle to not only enjoy, but to also shove into this pompous idiot's face at a range I shoot at. I am mostly a Garand guy, I also shoot Springfields and I comepte in NRA High Power with the M1 Garand and a match AR. A friend of mine bought the Remington 700 Sps tactical in .308 and he seems to enjoy it. I was always contemplating getting a commercial bolt gun for deer hunting anyway, but what motivated me really to buy the XL7 was , A) the reviews online as far as accuracy goes, B) I have over 10k rounds of surplus 30-06 and it all reloadable & C) there is this a$$ at our range who is the type of guy that if your car does 100 mph, his does 105mph. If you catch 12 fish, he catches 13 and his are bigger. He has a new Weatherby Mark V Deluxe rifle in 30-06 and he mounted a new Leupold scope on it. He paid big $$$ for his rig. Is set out to find the most economically accurate production bolt rifle in 30-06 made today and upon investigating this the Marlin XL7 was mentioned all the time. So I bought mine brand new off Gunbroker. I paid a grand sum of $305 (s&h was included), $20 for the FFL transfer, $335 for a new Nikon Monarch 3-12X42 mm scope, $35 for mount & base and then $99 for a Harris bipod. Without the bi-pod, I am out $695. He paid over $2500 for his setup. Now I am not knocking the Weatherby rifle. I am sure its a fine weapon and is nice to shoot and all that good stuff that makes one warm and fuzzy owning one. But, the rubber meets the road and the results are what counts.
I went out and bought a deck of playing cards and brought them out to the range. When my Weatherby friend showed up we had a little friendly competition. I took all the clubs out of the deck. I gave him the three of clubs and I took the two of clubs. Whoever could get the closest grouping by shooting out one club using four shots would win. We were shooting at 100 yards. Keep in mind, I was using neck sized reloads with a 150 grain Hornady FMJBT 3037 bullet over 45 grains of IMR 4320. COAL was 3.31. He was using his reloads too. Long story short, my $300 Marlin out shot his $2000 Weatherby. Again, is it the gun or the shooter? I'm sure it's both. But I love the fact that he had it thrown in his face that a cheap Marlin rifle outdid his Gucci gun.
MIke