My brother has the bodyguard and I have a first gen lcp. The Smith has better sights, the Ruger is a little trimmer, thanks to the laser on the S&W. Speaking of which, the laser doesn't get much use. It's hard to see in daylight, and once switched on, it is constant on, unlike a crimson trace. Trigger seems about the same, maybe a little lighter on the bodyguard, but not by much. Both have been very reliable. Note: the newer lcps have improved sights and triggers. I use a Remora and he uses a Sticky for both pocket and IWB carry. That's a good price on the BG.