The truth is always buried in the story - Merged Threads

3_21_101107_arsenal01.jpg


This is still one more case of "erring on the side of caution" and now they have to punish someone to save face.

Here's the latest from foxnews.

http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,301379,00.html

FOXNEWS.COM HOME > U.S.

Police: Mother Bought Guns for Pennsylvania Boy Charged With School Plot
Friday, October 12, 2007

NORRISTOWN, Pa. — A troubled teenager accused of plotting a school attack built up a stash of weapons with the help of his mother, authorities said.

Michele Cossey, 46, was arrested Friday on charges of illegally buying her home-schooled son, Dillon, a .22-caliber handgun, a .22-caliber rifle and a 9 mm semiautomatic rifle with a laser scope.

The parents were indulging the boy's interests because he was unhappy, not knowingly aiding a school assault, Montgomery County District Attorney Bruce Castor said Friday. The parents didn't know of the teen's plans, but "by virtue of her indulgence, she enabled him to get in this position," Castor said.

Authorities have said they do not believe an attack was imminent and are not even certain one would have occurred.

"This was a smart kid that clearly believes he was picked on and was a victim," Castor said. "He had psychological issues and began to act out on those feelings."

Dillon Cossey, who was arrested Wednesday, felt bullied and tried to recruit another boy for a possible attack at Plymouth Whitemarsh High School, authorities said. The teen previously attended middle school in the district, but had been taught at home for more than a year after voluntarily leaving school.

Acting on a tip from high school student, Lewis Bennett III and his father, police searched the boy's bedroom and found the 9 mm rifle, about 30 air-powered guns modeled to look like higher-powered weapons, swords, knives, a bomb-making book, videos of the 1999 Columbine attack in Colorado and violence-filled notebooks, Castor said.

The mother bought the semiautomatic rifle at a gun show on Sept. 23 and provided police with a receipt, investigators said in court papers. The teenager said the two .22-caliber weapons were stored at a friend's house.

She was charged with unlawful transfer of a firearm, possession of a firearm by a minor, corruption of a minor, endangering the welfare of a child and two counts of reckless endangerment, and later released on bail. She did not comment at the hearing.

Her attorney, Tim Woodward, said, "I'm sure she loves her kid."

The teen, who also had a brief court appearance Friday, was ordered held at a juvenile facility while he receives psychiatric evaluation. He was charged with solicitation to commit terror and other counts, but his lawyer, J. David Farrell, stressed that all but one of the weapons prosecutors put on display were pellet guns and air rifles.

At a press conference in their Conshohocken, Pa. home, the parents of the teen who tipped police off about the possible school attack, praised their son.

"We are really proud of our son, his maturity, and the way he is handling the media," said Lewis Bennett, Jr., the boy's father. "Wednesday my son learned of new information and that added to the information he had. That is what seemed to make it a more serious event. That is why we went to the police department."

While Dillon Cossey had been to their house, the teen's mother was concerned about him.

"(His) preoccupation with guns, when he would call the house and my son wasn't available, he would call persistently," said Lewis Bennett III's mother. "Things that make a red flag, but not sure of what is going on. He was always polite. A soft spoken child child."

It is legal for children to possess air guns in Pennsylvania. Farrell also noted it is legal for a minor to fire weapons under adult supervision and said he didn't believe the students at Plymouth Whitemarsh were in any danger.

"They're showing 30 guns on a desk that appear to be handguns and saying this was a Columbine in the making," Farrell said. "That's simply not borne out by the facts."

Dillon Cossey told investigators he was planning an attack on the school, Castor said, but authorities do not believe he was close to pulling it off. Castor said he believes the teen Cossey asked to help him was the first person he approached for assistance.

On his MySpace page, Dillon Cossey made frequent references to Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold and describes their 1999 massacre at Columbine High School as one of his interests. The page, headlined "Mess with the best, Die like the rest," features tribute videos to the Columbine shooters and includes a still from surveillance video of the attack.

Police, who searched the boy's home with his parents' permission, also discovered seven explosive devices Castor has described as homemade grenades: plastic containers filled with BBs to which gunpowder could be added. Authorities said one was operable and the others had been in the process of being assembled.

The search did not turn up any ammunition for the semiautomatic rifle.

Castor said he suspects Cossey "was a target for bullies because he was overweight and not fully developed socially," but that mental problems might have exaggerated the effect of the bullying.

"I have read things that he wrote. ... He has severe mental disturbances," Castor said.

Authorities said Friday that the boy's father also tried to buy his son a rifle in December 2005, but was not allowed to because he was a felon.

Frank Cossey was sentenced to house arrest for lying about his criminal record when he went to buy a .22-caliber rifle, police said Friday. On his application he said he had never been convicted of a felony, but he had pleaded guilty in 1981 to manslaughter in a drunken driving death in Oklahoma and sent to prison, police said.

The boy's arrest came the same day a 14-year-old in Ohio opened fire at his Cleveland high school, wounding four before killing himself.

The high school student who tipped off police with his father told the Philadelphia Daily News he was "sick of hearing about all these school shootings."

"I didn't want another kid to do the same thing and keep this chain of events going on," Lewis Bennett said.

Michele Cossey faces a maximum sentence of up to seven years in prison on the gun-transfer charge alone, but the prosecutor expects she would get a lighter sentence.

Yeah, she is a big gal who walks with the aid of a walker and would likely cost the state a fortune in medical fees if they were to jail her.
 
Notice the implication that she had to get the gun at a gun show because the NICS would not allow a store buy?

BTW- when I was a kid, I kept my BB's in a milk jug. I guess that was a bomb by the standard being applied here.
 
What are the chances of anyone or any group holding LE accountable for deliberate misrepresentation. This thing stinks more every day.
 
Guns like this are available through mail order and gun shows...

Notice the statement made in the story that NEVER says that these are airsoft or BB/pellet guns. Highly implies that you (14 year old) can go out on the internet or gun show and buy the weapons (see the scarey AKs and Uzi) without saying that these are essentially non-guns for the other plan of a Columbine type event.
I would really like to see one of our pro-2A organizations in an interview to clarify the types of weapons and the requirements to buy weapons.
 
Not that I wouldn't like the ATF to disappear or at least be knocked down to enforcing laws in their mere plain language, but I don't think the ATF is responsible here.

Even they wouldn't call a bunch of BBs in a plastic cup a grenade.
 
. . . . . but I don't think the ATF is responsible here.
Mostly likely true. But I don't see evidence of bATFE going out of its way to correct any misconceptions created by the photograph.
 
They already provide information regarding the definitions of, and the distinctions between airsoft, paintball, and real steel. I don't see anything else they could provide doing much, here; both the police and the media are going out of their way to confuse the matter, so I doubt sending them a correction would do much.

I think the last thing we need is the BATFE calling press releases whenever they feel like it.
 
"possession of an instrument of crime"

Do you own a .22 pistol or a 9mm rifle that happens to be the same model used at Columbine? Then you possess an "instrument of crime." Nice. Just when I thought prosecutors could not get any more slimy and defense attorneys could not get any more incompetent I read this story.

Yea, the kid has some problems with bullies. Yea, he's got some fantasies that are bad. But calling a cup of BBs a "grenade?" Come on. Let's start teaching some law in the schools. Let's start teaching people how to defend themselves in court and how to say "NO!" to requests for warrantless searches. :mad::mad: We're teaching people how to defend themselves against physical attack, but this story is proof that the public has no idea how to defend themselves legally.

http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20071026/ap_on_re_us/student_arsenal;_ylt=Ao_kpBy6rVzK9baDJW2k1Oms0NUE
 
At least the article called it a semiautomatic rifle and not an "assault rifle." I was pleasantly surprised to see that they didn't try to spin it with improper terminology.
 
Owning a similar model firearm as those used in the Columbine massacre is of no consequence and nothing in the article implied otherwise.
 
Owning a similar model firearm as those used in the Columbine massacre is of no consequence and nothing in the article implied otherwise.

In fact, I found after reading the article that the situation (as reported) was almost nothing like how the OP made it sound.
 
I am trying to figure out what the OP is talking about. Sounded like a good article to me, a lot better than the original reports made it out.


Edited to add: Since the merge, PT111 is talking about post #30. - Antipitas

That is correct on the post by tooltimey. The original media reports on this case were wild and crazy but this one seemed logical and well thought out and informed. It also added a lot of insight into the whole deal rather than just a bunch of hysteria.
 
Last edited:
Since this is the result of a previous thread (that is still open) that is only 2 weeks old, I've merged them.

The "search" function is your friend.
 
Turnabout is fair play?

If owning a firearm of the same model used at Columbine means you own an "insrument of crime", does this mean that if you own a Glock, or a S&W (which are used by the police) that you own an "instrument of law enforcement"?
 
Back
Top