Suggestions for first .357 Magnum Medium Frame

This one has to go to Smith & Wesson and the K frame M19. While I cant condone the purchase of a new one the used market is very much alive and well. From what I have seen of the new one's I dont think much of them. I wont be buying new ones even if they had not made their deal with the devil.

------------------
No man is above the law and no man is below it,nor do we ask any mans permission when we require him to obey it.
 
What is the difference between the GP-100 and the GP-141 and GP-161 the Ruger website lists them and they all seem really similar.
 
Gary,

I've got an SP101 and a M66 in .357. I really like them both.

The 66 is substantially larger than the SP, and heavier. The trigger feels smoother, even though I've dry fired the SP to an acceptable level. The rear sight on the 66 is adjustable, and the front sight is raised and orange. All in all, it is a much nicer revolver, and is more fun to shoot than the workmanlike SP101.

Don't get me wrong, I love the SP. It is my "beater", the one firearm I take with me on the roadtrips and backpacking, etc.

However, If I were to choose a "target" .357, I'd probably pick up an N-frame, either the 27 or 28. They are the original platform, as stated above, for the .357 cartridge, which was loaded much hotter originally than it is today. An N-frame revolver will withstand repeated firing of high pressure loads. The N-frame is bulkier, but it doesn't bother me. If you have the opportunity to handle one, check the cylinder and you will appreciate its massive design.

The 27 is the deluxe model, with many variations of sights available, in addition to a serrated top and deluxe finish. Originally, these revolvers came in an "eye popping" nickel blue, called "Magna Blue". Later Smith went to a black finish. I've seen these used for as little as $250 and up to $650 for "presentation" boxed weapons.

The 28 is the more affordable version, without so many options, but otherwise identical. I think they run about $200 to $275 and up for the good examples.

If you want to know more about the N-frame, you might check out the pistols section of Assaultweb.com, moderated by Dadduck, an avowed N-frame nut. He is eager to dole out info about these weapons.

Hope this helps!

Regards,
--
Brian
 
Gary,

Sorry, I blew it. It's actually:
http://assaultweb.net/cgi-bin/Ultimate.cgi

I have trouble accessing it from time to time, but it's worth checking back if it's offline.

In particular, there is a "Practical handgun training" thread in the Pistol and Handgun section that may be of interest. I used the first part of it to train my woman in use of a revolver. She preferred my P7 though... Oops!

Best,
--
Brian
 
GP-100 is everything a Smith is and more.

Remember, a GOOD gunsmith can always make an action smoother if necessary. My GP-100 is as accurate as any old S&W is and is MUCH stronger (i.e. better built). Plus it is less expensive too boot.

Ruger also has a great customer service dept.

Can't go wrong with a GP-100, any way you turn!!!



------------------
"By His stripes we are healed..."

PeterGunn
 
Back
Top