starter shotgun
The Pheasants Forever chapter that I belong to (Logan Creek) has been holding a youth mentor hunt for 10 years now. During that time, we have had approximately 240 kids go through the program. In order to participate, they must have completed the state hunter ed. course and be 12 or older (so basically 12-15). Several years ago, our chapter purchased 5, 870 20 ga. youth model shotguns for use at this event, basically to ensure that all of the kids had a safe, dependable shotgun to use that should fit them fairly well. As part of the program, we take them out to shoot some blue rocks in order to get familiar with the gun, and help them learn a little about shooting.
I've watched and helped an awful lot of kids during that time, and I would say that these shotguns, while "fitting" as far as length is concerened are too heavy, especially front heavy for most of the younger ones that we work with. When they bring the gun up, they shift their hips forward and upper body back to try hold the barrel up and maintain their balance. A lot of them don't have the strength and stability to hold the weight of the shotgun with their left hand in this new, unusual position. When we work on proper shooting position, they just about tip over forward, at least for the first few times they shoulder the gun. We can then get them into position, but starting to work on swing and follow thru, they lose it again and go back to "hips forward leaning back" position that they started with.
My personal view is that a good starter gun for smaller kids would be a single barrel for better balance, light loads, with a good recoil pad, and possibly even add some weight or a recoil dampener into the buttstock. Probably the best thing would be to work a lot on stance, stability, balance, and strength, before they ever get to shoot. Remember the old game where two kids grab each other's hands and try to push/pull the other one off balance? Start with that to show them the importance of a solid foundation and balance, then give them an empty gun, or bb gun, toy gun, whatever and have them practice mounting/swinging it a lot before ever letting them shoot.
Anyway, I've rambled on long enough, and thats my 2 cents worth.
Me? The first shotgun I ever fired was a 12 ga. M24 Winchester, The first one I got to carry hunting was a 20 ga. bolt action borrowed from a cousin, and then when I was 13 dad bought me 12 ga. High Standard pump 2 3/4" chamber modified choke that I used on everything- doves, quail, prairie chickens, sharptails, pheasants, ducks, geese and turkeys (and a few other non bird critters) for 20+ years. I've bought a few others recently, but I never did like one as well.
bergie