<BLOCKQUOTE><font size="1" face="Verdana, Arial">quote:</font><HR>Originally posted by RWK:
I am not attempting to start -- and I absolutely do not want -- a "flame" by this question for all you snubbie fans.
I am concerned that any two to three inch revolver barrel will not produce sufficient muzzle velocity for a high-probability, immediately disabling wound. Obviously, this is particularly worrisome with .38 Special rounds as contrasted to .357 magnum loads. Please set me straight. Why do you feel a snubbie provides adequate self-protection compared to either a longer barreled (e.g., four inch) revolver or many types of autoloaders?
[/quote]
Everything is a trade off...
The snubbies provide very reliable, very concealable protection. You don't have to remember to rack the slide (although I've never done that...yet).
I'm not particularly concerned about killing the assailant. All I want to do is stop him/her so I can get away. I am very confidant that .38 Spl will do this. I am also concerned about potential misses (remember, we're in a high stress situation here). Where do those rouns go? If you hit a passerby with a round, you will be in deep doodoo (if not criminally, you'll likely have a helluva lawsuit on your hands).
Now, I carry both snubbie revolvers and other sidearms up to a Glock 19 (depends on how I'm dressing...where I'm going, etc.). Any of them (including my wife's .32ACP Beretta Tomcat) provide me with the security I need or desire in a real world situation.