Great thread
Let me preface this by saying that I just turned 53 years old, I am 5'9" and 150 lbs, with a spinal fusion surgery two years ago. Just to say I am not the picture of youth or strength, and I don't have a lot extra muscle or padding, or 20 years worth of experience carrying or anything like that....if I can do it, you can probably do it too.
I've been shooting for quite a while, but after living in CA for 20 years and IL for another three, it was only since I moved to Texas in 2004 and got my CHL that my "evolution" began. Suddenly I had the opportunity to try and carry some of the pistols I owned, and I had an obligation to develop and maintain a degree of proficiency (although it was a fairly enjoyable burden).
When I took my initial qualification, I used my Glock G23, so I thought that it was the natural choice to CCW with. Maybe not. Never could find a holster that allowed me to carry it comfortably and conceal it effectively. I also bought a G-19, but they both went away for the same reason. Too fat, too heavy, and I never shot more than "reasonably well" with that trigger (246 of 250 on that initial Texas CHL test, which really isn't anything to brag about, but I was pretty satisfied with it at the time).
During that initial course of instruction, the CHL instructor talked quite a bit about how a j-frame was a very good carry weapon, and I ended up going through a series of them, in steel, aluminum and Scandium. Spent a lot of money on j-frames, but I never shot a j-frame very well.
In this time frame, I also tried a number of other revolvers ranging from .44Spls in steel (Taurus 431, S&W 696) and Scandium (S&W M-396) and .45 acp in Scandium (S&W M-325). Some were easy to shoot, none were easy to conceal. All are long gone.
I also owned several Para 45s, from small steel single-stack C-6s (two each) to the P-14. I shot them all well, but each was too big/too heavy/etc. All are long gone.
When I found the Kahr PM9, I discovered a pistol that I could pocket carry, I could shoot well, and I was happy...for a while. But I am fickle, and always searching for the Next Great Thing...so then I entered my Dark Period.
I saw the Kel-Tec P-11 and said hey, same size as my PM9, but 10+1 and about half the price of the PM-9...what's not to like? Picked one up. About the same time, a co-worker offered me a P3AT for a great price, and I also found a P-32 too cheap to pass up. Before it was all done, I had two P3ATs, the P-11 and the P-32. Only problem was, none of them worked..I spent a lot of time on KTOG, got to know F&B procedures pretty well, got to know a certain K-T CS guy by first name as he was shipping me springs-and-stuff every week...
Long story short, all K-Ts are long gone and it will be a cold day in a very warm place before I look at another one. Back to the Kahr PM9, and happy again....
However, the guy I shoot with owns a Kimber Pro Carry (steel 4" 1911), and one evening he let me shoot it. Suddenly I realized why his targets always looked better than mine, and had a nice neat hole punched out of the center. Yes, he's a good shot, but that 1911 made me look pretty good too. As I handed it back to him, I said something to the effect of, wish you hadn't done that. That's going to cost me a lot of money...
I bought my first Kimber about a month later, and have owned seven since then. Although I've owned at least a dozen 1911s, the only ones I currently own are Kimbers, and until I can afford a Wilson, I think I'll stick with them. I currently have two steel 5 inch ones that I take to the range, and two 3 inch alloy ones that are in the carry rotation. They all make me look good.
Since the Kahr PM9 had treated me so well, I added a P45, and started carrying it during what we laughingly call "Winter" (defined as any time a sweatshirt can be worn). An 18 oz .45 acp that works every time and also makes me look good...hard not to like.
Somewhere along the way, my revolver tastes turned more toward the larger frames...first Ks, then an L and finally the N-frames. I currently own 4" S&Ws in K-frame (.357) and N-frame (.45 LC, .45 acp and .41 Mag). These have also entered the "Winter" rotation.
I started reloading about three years ago, started shooting more frequently (trying for once a week, and not doing too badly) and regularly shooting larger caliber guns fairly well led me to the conclusion that I should regularly carry a larger caliber, if at all possible.
Last winter, I decided that when Springtime came, I would not transition back to the PM9 as I had been doing for the last three years. I stuck with the P45 throughout the summer. It has been relatively painless, and I have confidence in both my platform and my abilities.
The PM9 sits forlornly in the safe. It's the best pocket pistol I've ever owned, but I'd rather carry the P45. I also bought an LCP about a year ago, and have put probably 300 rounds through it, but have never carried it. At least it works, unlike all those Kel-Tecs...but if I can carry a .45, why would I carry a .380? Not to say that there will not come a day when the PM9 or the LCP won't serve a purpose...that's why neither of them has been sold, when so many others have.
I have skipped over a number of others owned concurrently...if I stopped and thought about how much money I have spent in the last five years looking for The Perfect Carry Pistol, I'd probably just declare bankruptcy and move on.
Better to just be thankful for what I have. As it stands, as of today
the carry pistols I cannot live without are:
1. Kahr P45. Not pretty, not sexy. Light (18 oz), accurate beyond any reason, dead reliable.
2. Kimber Stainless Ultra Carry, with TruGlo TFOs and Crimson Trace, frame Cera-Koted like an Ultra CDP. Drop dead gorgeous, 24 oz, deadly accurate, almost too pretty to carry. Almost.
3. S&W M-25-2 in .45 acp. Cut down to 3", about 38 oz, smooth as silk.
4. S&W M-25-5 in .45LC, 4". Custom trigger, hammer, etc. by Hamilton Bowen. Nicest S&W trigger I've ever experienced. About 40 oz.
Note that the P45 gets carried more than all of the others combined, and tonight I managed a five-shot goup though one ragged hole at 21 feet. Yeah, I think I can live with that.