scourge of the earth... those early custom guns... why no love ???

I think the rarity of the Fitz Special speaks to their popularity. Ed McGivern didn't think too well of them, neither did Bill Jordan, Skeeter Skelton mentioned butchering a few guns in that way. About the only real gunman who actually used one was Charlie Askins.
That Combat Masterpiece that was turned into a PPC gun was a regular production model at the time, hence not a rarity.
I am a collector and one of those responsible for "collectormania". I have a rack of milsurp safe queens, like preserving-or restoring-an old house or a military vehicleI think I am preserving a bit of history-that's what the late Charles Stratton wrote when he inscribed my copies of his books. You want to build your own rifle, IMHO a modern current production rifle built with high standards of quality control will be more satisfactory that say a pre-64 Winchester or a late war Mauser built by slave labor with inferior materials.
Just m $.02.
 
I am a collector and one of those responsible for "collectormania".

So am I, but I was trying to make a point.:p

I've got a couple of safe queens that I would love to shoot, but I don't dare. One is a pristine Lee-Speed rifle that looks like it just came from BSA, and the other is a Smith & Wesson .32 auto.

I think my late cousin summed it up best when he told me one time that we aren't the owners of these guns, only the custodians.
 
One of the coolest guns ever discussed on this forum was "Nana's gun" from 2009. Remember that one? It was an N-frame S&W 357 that had been used by a female Alaskan bush pilot of some repute, and had been pressed into service as a bear deterrent at least once.

It turned out to be a WW1 45ACP critter, retrofitted with a cylinder from a large-frame 38Spl and the barrel off a real S&W 357. With cheap plastic "stag" grips.

Under cold conditions those grips would have actually been practical. The gun shot just fine and can be linked to the saving of at least one life, probably more. Wonderful piece and I hope his family never parts with it:

http://thefiringline.com/forums/showthread.php?t=380951

I won't even start with Maurice, which is an engineering testbed/prototype for all kinds of weird tech and isn't fully done yet. I may end up figuring out how to get it to eat out of Glock 33rd mags, which would be a neat trick on a New Vaquero :). I'm already up to 14rd capacity with no reloads, homebrew mags and a six-shot cylinder from a Bowen blank in 9mmPara.
 
Carcano bayonets were cheaper than re-bar,

And this is essentially the crux of the matter. OH NO! LOOK what some idiot did that rare expensive piece of history! :eek:

Except that it wasn't a rare expensive anything when it was done.

And even if it was something done to a fairly rare gun then, if it was done well, and pleased the owner, who are we to judge?

Today I saw a sporterized Johnson rifle, the one that competed against the Garand. Nice finish, looked nearly new, pretty wood with a full Monte Carlo rollover stock.

Today, a collector would pay more for a more beat up one in GI trim. He would get a better collector piece, but he wouldn't be getting a better rifle.

A trigger job technically makes a gun a custom job, but we rarely think of it that way. Unless we are going to buy one. And then we often react poorly, simply because there's no way to know if it was done right. Unless it comes with proof from a "name" gunsmith shop. Then it might be worth something, maybe...

So, maybe somebody put King sights on a "classic" old Colt SAA. Ruined the value of the gun, they did! Unless their name was Keith....

Everybody's got standards (mine are pretty low about some things, ;)) if you think its ruined, then for you, it is. For me, it might just be ...neat!
 
Whatever someone does to modify a gun they own, mine or anyone else’s opinion should have no bearing on the owner’s decision to modify the gun.
It’s their gun, if you want to paint it pink or make the side plate transparent, no business of mine.

OH NO! LOOK what some idiot did that rare expensive piece of history!


The attached is a Mod 28 that I had modified to shoot 44 specials with a 3 inch barrel.
30 years ago I paid 150$ for it.
The mod cost twice as much.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top