I picked up a real nice 2.5" 19-3 about a year ago for $450. It was in one of those little Twilight Zone shops and it was if it was calling my name as we drove by.
I also picked up a real nice 4" 19-5 for $400 a couple of months before that. Both are great shooters and lately, have been getting most of revolvers range time.
I don't like those soft rubber Hogue grips.
I dont like the looks of them either, but I have them on most of my K, L, and N frames. They are ugly (not as ugly as that new Ergo grip
), but they do fill my hand perfectly, lock the gun in my hand and make shooting almost Zen like.
I much prefer the issue magna type grips for "looks", and with a T grip, they are almost as nice as the Houges to shoot with, and nothing beats them for carry. Thats what my J frames wear, and just for that reason.
I keep meaning to check, but Houge used to have the rubber style grips in nylon as well. Those work much better if youre carrying.