Humpfff!
If Ayoob says it, I take leave to doubt it. His credibility would be far better if he didn't reverse his opinion twice in three years or so. Remember, In The Gravest Extreme has been in print for several yers, and he'll have changed his mind several times in the interim.
I'd like to see some figures from a respected Smith & Wesson collector who has personally inspected old company records, befor believing they've sold more Model 36s than the Military & Police models.
All that aside, there is some limited validity to the observations. Let's see--
Change the ejector rod to full stroke, enough to clear .38 Spl cases.
Install high profile, 1/8 inch front and adjustable rear, target sights. Increase sight radius by lengthening the two inch barrel to four inches.
Add another chamber to the cylinder, or, as is so popular today, make it a seven or eight shot cylinder.
NOW, you've cured those little shortfalls that Mr. Ayoob points out, and you have a GREAT little gun. Or, maybe not so little. Perhaps it is "improved" to the extent we'll need to call it something else. Like, Model 15 Combat Masterpiece? Or perhaps a Model 686?
Five shots makes for a narrower profile cylinder. Short barrel with the front end latch necessitates a short ejector rod stroke.
I personally believe the major problem with the Model 36 and most of the other J-frames is that they are really pretty heavy for compact arms. I much prefer the Model 37. I feel that S&W finally came out with the "ideal" pocket revolver just shortly before the reprehensible compromise (sellout, that is.) The Model 637 combines the best of the Models 37 and 60. Light enough weight for real pocket carry. Stainless steel parts to resist corrosion. The sights are also a tiny bit wider, for faster pickup. There is still a hammer spur, so you can elect to thumb cock for greater precision.
Let those criticize who wish. The Chief ready to hand will fend off a lot more bad guys than the bigger, easier-to-shoot handguns left in the car or locked in the gun safe.
Interestingly, I just realized that as I write this, l'm still wearing the Model 37 in the ankle holster I put it on at 6:30 a.m.
Best,
Johnny
PS--
C.R.S.--You reminded me I need to re-qualify with the Airweight at the end of this month. Thanks.
------------------
---The Second Amendment ensures the rest of the Bill of Rights---