S&W Model 17 - cocked issues

To answer someone else's question - there are indeed 4" model 17s in addition to 4" model 18s. I believe the 4" model 17-6 was introduced after they discontinued the model 18, though I could be wrong.
A 4" barrel can be added to a model 17, too, after sale. Not unheard of.
 
Borf,

Great! I don't think you will have too great a problem finding a new hammer for a K, though one could possibly fix the old one, the time it would take to straighten that out would probably cost more than a hammer. A good smith will be able to locate one, and may have it on hand.
 
"There really isn't a single action sear notch to speak of. At least any more. More of a rough little valley that's barely visible with some metal displaced towards the side of the hammer - maybe like someone used a file?"

Seen that more times than I care to remember.

Some years ago a friend brought me a Model 29 he had purchased pretty cheaply. He knew there was an issue with the single action, as it would push off, so he brought it to me to fix. There was so little single action engagement left that the hammer would drop if you shook the gun.

Fortunately, hammers are cheap (relatively speaking). It can make a difference as to which engineering change you order with at least some of the guns, so if you have a 17-2, try to get a hammer that's denoted as being for a 17-2.
 
Seen that more times than I care to remember.

Some years ago a friend brought me a Model 29 he had purchased pretty cheaply. He knew there was an issue with the single action, as it would push off, so he brought it to me to fix. There was so little single action engagement left that the hammer would drop if you shook the gun.
Could you determine, one way or the other, if it was Bubbaed, or if it was just wear?
 
I think it very unlikely that the hammer was damaged and the trigger is OK; you will probably have to replace both parts (and maybe something else) to get the gun working right again. That is when a "good deal" turns out to be "not so good deal".

Jim
 
Back
Top