My blackhawk was touchy and needed abnormal fussing inserting the cylinder. Replaced it with the double action redhawk and was happier. No doubt the Blackhawk cost less and was a very good shooter. I liked the single action and loading gate. But my cylinder just didn't want to go back in very well. And I had a second idea that I could load the gun and also use it for home apart from hunting. So the redhawk just fit that purpose a bit better. Makes it easier to clean and it's easier to flipflop 44 spc, 44mag defense & hunting ammo. Oh, and I didn't care for the factory grip on the Blackhawk so I put on a Hogue with finger grooves. Liked that much better.