ruger 22s: semi-auto vs revolver

I vote for a semi-auto Ruger MKxxx .22 over the SA cowboy type revolvers.
I do not like the grip of SA/Cowboy type revolvers.
I am not a big fan of the luger-like grip angle of the MK series but it still feels better than the single six grip. My MKIIs have wood laminate finger groove grips to compensate for the steep angle.
Also, It is easier to use the Semi --- loading and shooting (Note: the only SA rev i have tried was a Ruger Blackhawk .357/38).

Do not be scared off by the disassembly/assembly horror stories of MK series. Other pistols are easier to breakdown but MK series are not terrible.
 
Thanks for the continued advice regarding auto vs single six and 22/45 vs. MkIII's. I'm leaning away from the single six at the moment because of the grip size, and my hands are narrower than the person I'd be getting the gun for. As for letting the person decide and then getting the gun, I thought a better way would be just buy one, and if he doesn't like it, I can keep it and get him something else. :D
 
don't forget the Bisley Single Six. Way easier on my hand and I like the lower hammer thumb spur. The SA loading may be a PITA to some people, but not to me.
 
It's a hard question to answer, gun preference depends on the shooter. I have both. A modded MKIII Target with a red dot for fun shooting...
009-3.jpg

And a 9.5" Single Six scoped for hunting(can't hunt with a semi in PA)...
001-11.jpg

They both group about the same from a rest at 50 yards, with the MKIII being the winner for off hand shooting and quick target acquisition.
Can't go wrong either way!
 
Ok, you all are going to start thinking, "why can't this idiot just ask all his questions at once?" but here's a couple more:

1) On the MkIII, is there a noticeable difference in accuracy between the standard barrel and bull barrel models?

2) Are all models with adjustable sights also drilled and tapped for scope mounts? I know I've seen some fixed sight 22/45 models that weren't.
 
1) On the MkIII, is there a noticeable difference in accuracy between the standard barrel and bull barrel models?
Click to expand...

There is no difference in the actual accuracy of either, since the lighter barrel is still plenty heavy enough. There IS a noticeable difference in the balance, and many people find the nose-heavy balance of the heavier barrel easier to shoot accurately, with faster and better accuracy on follow up shots in rapid-type shooting.

Daryl
 
I vote for the semiauto Ruger.

A MKI used to live in my safe many years ago, 5.5" bull barrel, great shooting .22lr. Sad to say, I sold it 20 years ago.

Nineteen years ago, I purchased a Ruger Competition Target, 6.875" slab sided barrel, my grandson will one day own it.
 
I own four Ruger MK II's so you know my preference. The ease of reloading, and accuracy seals the deal for me. You won't use the mag cylinder much if at all. Have you seen the price of .22 mag ammo lately? You buy a .22 for cheap, fun shooting. The Ruger autos can be easily made match grade accurate with a few simple mods from Volquartsen or others. Even stock they are very accurate.

While I like SA revolvers, I still prefer a .22 auto.
 
I have a Ruger standard semi auto with 4.75" bbl and a target model with wood finger groove grips 6" bbl. Both long before the MK series (about 50+ yrs ago). I love them both and wouldn't consider getting rid of them. I have no idea of the dollar value, but as great shooters, they are priceless.

I also have a three screw .357 Blackhawk that shoots high even with the rear sight cranked as low as it will go. I sent it back to the factory for fixing. They modified it to the modern transfer system that is awful and clunky. I took it out and reinstalled the old parts to make it whole. It still shoots high, but I don't want to send if back because I'm afraid they will modify it again and not return the old parts.
 
My first gun purchase after leaving the service in 1976 was a Ruger MkII target model and I still have it. As a plunker it's hard to beat. I also have a Single Six Convertible and like it too. These two guns have seen the teaching of two sons to shoot and lead to other Ruger purchases over the years. I can't even begin to estimate the ammo that has gone through these two pistols between me, my wife and two sons. I have had no trouble with either one and AMt's clone of the MkII (which I also have) is a testament to the Ruger design. My AMT Lightning is a 10 inch bull barrel with a scope and has shot at least 30 Wood Chucks over the years here on the homestead. All three are excellent weapons and a good investment.
 
My AMT Lightning is a 10 inch bull barrel with a scope and has shot at least 30 Wood Chucks over the years here on the homestead. All three are excellent weapons and a good investment.
Click to expand...
"Dang Wood Chucks, QUIT CHUCKING MY WOOD!" ;)
 
Totally different types of guns. The semi auto will by and large be more accurate when using .22 LR ammunition. The reason for this is the convertible revolver has the bore sized for .22 Magnum because it uses a slightly larger dia. bullet. A .22 LR bullet going down a .22 Mag. bbl. will not give as good accuracy as a bullet correctly sized for the bore. The revolver will also have a much slower lock time. The slow locktime will give some shooters a problem and some others not. The Single Six I used to have was a tack driver out to 75 yards with .22 Mag. rounds but not really very accurate with LR ammo compared to a MK II semi.
 
I have a Ruger MarkII with Bull Barrel,way more accurrate than the H&R 900
revolver that rides in pocket sometimes. Ya gotta put a bit of Kentucky windage on H & R. I sold an old target 900 or aws it 999:confused: accurate as heck but grip was wayyyyy to small for my mitt. :mad:
 
Ask the recipient which they like better,,,

You should be able to sneak this in conversation somewhere,,,
Just find out which they think is cooler,,,
A revolver or a semi-auto?

Aarond
 
If I was on the receiving end I would want the auto but,
that is just me.

Does the person you are buying the gift have more revolvers
or autos? this would give us a better clue as to what they like?

If its a first gun the revolver is much easier to clean than
to field strip the Ruger auto :D
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top