I think the op made the right decision. Best accuracy between the two rifles in question will probably be, as AllenJ opined, a "crapshoot". I've used Ruger bolt-action rifles (Model 77s and MKIIs) since the early seventies and have never had a problem with any of them. I like the ruggedness and dependability of the Ruger and if you want a 3-position safety, crf, built-in mount (with scope rings included) and a Mauser-like extractor, the choice (as opposed to the otherwise fine Remington Model 700) has to be a Ruger.