Recommend a good value hunting knife

JohnCrighton

New member
I have a Buck knife with curved blade, about 3"-3.5" long blade, half of it serrated. I feel like, for hunting small-medium game, I might need something else. Maybe something with a gut-hook, no serration, similar length blade.

What is a good value (i.e. not ultra-cheap, but good quality without breaking the bank) knife out there that would meet these criteria? Or do you have other suggestions?

Thanks!
 
John,
Greethings. I never have needed anythng with a hook. I always have used the two fingers with knife between them for skinning down the front of the gut bag. I do like a drop point, not a sharp point for skinning. I am 44, and have had a Case XX since I was about 21. The kind with two blades, doesn't lock. It had skinned 67 deer by the time I was 25. I quit counting at that point in time. From reading your posts, it looks like you have done a lot of skinning yourself. If I was to buy something new, it would probably be a fixed blade, not over 3.5" long, with a drop point. I have several nice, expensive Cold Steels, a Trailmaster and a Recon Tanto, long knives. I have a 5" Benchmade tanto folder, none have ever been any good for skinning or even backpacking and camping. A large knife has never been a tool that I needed. You can't even peel 'taters with a big knife.

Best - Ted
 
I would look at the Buck Gen 5, it was listed in very well recently by Field and Stream. A std model one will be about $50.
 
There are several smaller knives that I recommend for hunting. I use my Buck 311 Trapper most of the time. The current pocket resident has gone through 5 deer; gutted, skinned (yup), boned, and trimmed. The Case 3254 Trapper is basically the same knife by Case. I have a Remington bird knife with a single blade and guthook that has a choke tube wrench also; it went through it's second deer last week. Frost Cutlery has 2 good ones; both have surgical steel blades which really hold an edge, and are dirt cheap. One has a 30/06 cartridge on the handle, single blade, and is my everyday carry knife; the other has a blue handle and has 2 blades shaped like the Trapper knives above. I bought both at the gunshow for $5 each. For a fixed blade, I like the #3 Finn Case knife; around $40. Buck is making a smaller version of the 311 now, and I bought one for my springoff last year for Christmas; it was $12 and tax at Wally World. Unfortunately it's made in China, but seems to be of good steel and holds an edge well. Any of the above has a 3" or shorter blade, and is just right for reaching up inside the deer and cutting the windpipe. They also work well for skinning muskrats and small fur bearers, and for small game such as squirrels, birds, and rabbits. You could look at the Buck 500 and 501 as well; Case and Old Timer make a Muskrat that has 2 blades that are the same. Very handy for lots of skinning chores.
 
Last edited:
Case trapper or the like. I really like case as they are made in the U.S.A, I also like the Old Timer series but Schrade sold out to overseas manufacturing:barf:
 
The Buck Gen 5 is made in the US as are most of their knives.

If you check the Buck website you'll see little US flags next to the ones made in the US.

There is talk that they are going to bring all production back to the US which would be great!

Several of the 300 series folders are still US made if you want one of them.
 
Gerber has always been my choice because I grew up in Oregon. I use the Gator folding knife and haven't had problems with it. But most any knife will do if it's sharp.
 
A modern Puukko knife with a carbon steel blade. Very inexpensive to boot.

m571.jpg


http://www.kellamknives.com/index.p...=129&gad=CIHFuIIDEggJcZBVcEjclxj7keT6AyCtyLIi
 
I've been carrying a Browning FDT (Field Dressing Tool) for several years. Can't remember when it came out. I also picked up it's newer brother when it came out. I love it. It's got the blade, gut-hook with razor blade, and bone saw. The saw also works great on stray tree limbs that need trimming. This is what I carry most of the time. It's the newer brother.



Browning FDT.JPG
 
I have a buck caping knife, it seem to work just fine. Plenty sharp, has a gut hook (which I never use) and it's small enough to have good control so you don't make any unintentional slips into things you don't want to cut. If I were to buy another tomorrow, it would probably be a buck woodsman. I'm with Ted on the gut hook thing, it's pretty useless, just use a couple fingers to guide and it just seems to work better. If you are set on some sort of gut hook though, I'd go with the Wyoming knife, but once you open the deers belly, a traditional knife works better.
 
To me, it's not so much the size as the radius of the blade. I CAN do any animal with a Swiss Army knife but here we don't have a lot of time due to temperature. I use a large flat blade with a lot of radius to get things (especially skinning) done in a hurry.
 
Creature

Great knifes are made up there aren't they? I've found the laminated stainless knives are also great products.

Best

S-
 
Good hunting knife

CPM s30v, completely hand made, beautiful wood handles and custom leather sheath :) It's what I do.... lol, thanks for looking.

Andy

P1010507.jpg


Also, the one below is currently on e-bay and you could pick up for under $150.....

P1010509.jpg
 
I own a Buck General that I purchased in 1961. It has been my hunting companion all these years and also accompanied me "across the pond". It has lived up to all their claims and is indeed a wonderful piece of cutlery.
 
K-bar makes some good quality hunting knives at affordable prices. I have a gerber gator thats going on 13yrs and still going strong. My favorite folder is a CRKT m-16 though atm, and the k-bar skinner for fixed.
 
Back
Top