I'm not trying to scare anyone off, but I will admit to being a bigger fan of the New Model Rugers than I am of the Colts. Except for them not being "traditional" I find them better suited to me than Colts. I also like oversize rubber grips. My thing, and in no way meaning to disparage the colts/clones. I am very traditional about a lot of other things. (not a fan of plastic on guns, with certain limited exceptions, for one, and call it what you want, polymer is plastic, for one example, and don't like crossbolt safeties on Marlins and Winchesters, for another...)
I have a number of traditional guns, levers,bolts, single shots, etc, I just happen to like the modern Ruger SA's. Had an unconverted old model Blackhawk (.41mag) a long time ago. I know the traditional fairly well. I just can't understand people who get a ruger, and then want it to work like the traditional colt. IF that's what's important, get the COLT!
Now, here's what you do to cock the colt quietly...hold the trigger back, pull the hammer all the way back, the let go of the trigger, while holding the hammer back. Then ease the hammer down until it catches on the full cock notch, and you're ready to go. Fast, quiet, and as safe as you are.
ok, its not totally silent, but it is MUCH quieter than letting it click through C-O-L-T
For love of nostalgia, enjoy the clicks, and everything else when plinking. Work it right when hunting and you aren't spooking the game, either.