There are not generally any premium values attached to unfired Italian replica revolvers except very unusual and rare specimens.
I just didn't want to be the moron who broke some collector's heart.
BTW, you need to brown the cylinder pin and hammer on that 58. They look kinda funny next to the rest of it. Other than that they both look good.
Yeah, I had half a box of 451s that seemed to shoot fine out of my Uberti '58.I have a Pietta 1858 and have had great results with .451 Speer balls.