Homerboy said:
how would you respond if you're standing at a roadblock and a car accelerates towards you? Does it matter what the intent of the driver is coming at you? He's going to flatten you either way, so you light him up. No difference here.
Well, if a car sped towards a roadblock I was manning, of course I'd take out the driver. Then again, VBIEDs are more common in Iraq then New York...if we were
just talking about a car, accelerating from a stop, I'd think "getting out of the way" would be step one, followed by perhaps
restrained fire. Innocent bystanders and all.
That, or I'd let my .50 gunner put a few in the engine.
209 said:
Allegedly, the gun has also been recovered. Funny thing, the shell cases found in the SUV are said to match the handgun, which "had the serial number removed". Gee, I guess that puts a gun in the car.
Link? And no, if this ends up being the case I'd probably give the PD benefit of the doubt and say it's likely the gun actually came from the car.
12-34hom said:
The poster who pointed out that the answer lies between the two extremes views is right on track.
Hard to argue with this. I will say that as more details like this come out my opinion on the matter definitely starts to shift. I'd like to see a few more sources backing this up (not a huge fan of the NY Post), but still I'll say this might look a little more "complicated" than it did originally.
homerboy said:
And then we have the no nothing Monday Morning Quarterbacks on this board who think they have the experience to second guess them, while they choose to believe the word of three career felons over these cops.
It isn't about believing one word
over another, it's about failing to take
either side's word unconditionally. I'd never say "hey, those ex-cons are obviously more trustworthy than cops." I just would not say that cops are guaranteed to be telling the truth
just because they are cops.
As far as second-guessing before the evidence comes in, without a public willing to question the actions of police there'd be no end to what the few bad cops out there could get away with. Yes, it means from time to time I'll be
wrong. I'm okay with that. But police officers need to understand that by taking on what really is a position of power over the "common man," they are holding themselves up to a high level of public scrutiny. And once again my answer is that if you don't like this, a career in sales might fit you better.
I still say their use of firearms in this case was, at best, a bit irresponsible.
Also, I think I explained why I feel the term "Monday Morning Quarterback" in ludicrous in this situation.
Lastly,
Come on, where are you JuanCarlos? Where are you Camp David?
Um...working? I'd say the case is still a little way from being settled...no rush here.