Mom: Son Killed Teacher by Accident

Skyhawk

New member
http://www.apbnews.com/newscenter/breakingnews/2000/06/01/teachshoot0601_01.html

Mom: Son Killed Teacher by Accident
Jailed Fla. Teen Awaiting Grand Jury Action in Shooting
June 1, 2000

WEST PALM BEACH, Fla. (AP) -- Polly Powell rushed home when she saw reports of a shooting at her son's school on television. She knew 13-year-old Nathaniel Brazill had been sent home for throwing water balloons, and she was concerned for his welfare.

He wasn't there when she arrived. Soon, the phone started ringing off the hook as the nation learned that her son was suspected of killing a teacher he "loved."

"My sister called and said, 'Polly, you need to go to the police department and see if they got that boy.' It never dawned on me that this could be my child to do such an act," Powell told The Associated Press in her first interview since the May 26 shooting.

Brazill has been accused of killing 35-year-old Lake Worth Community Middle School teacher Barry Grunow. Police say Brazill shot Grunow in the face with a .25-caliber semiautomatic pistol he had stolen from his grandfather's house.

Caught on tape

After being sent home, Brazill returned to the school and went to Grunow's classroom, where he asked Grunow if he could talk to two girls in the class, police said.

When the English teacher shooed him away, Brazill pulled the gun from his pocket and fired, authorities said. A surveillance camera caught the shooting on tape, but police haven't released the video.

Powell rushed to the police department. She kept asking an officer if her son was there. When he said yes, she began trembling and shaking, saying that it couldn't be her child. Officers took her to a room where Brazill sat alone.

'They were best friends'

The teen began crying when his mother walked in. All she could do was hold him, Powell said.

The mother said the shooting had to be an accident.

"He loved Mr. Grunow. They were best friends," said Powell, a cook at an Episcopal retirement center for the last 11 years. "You don't just shoot your best friend. This was just an accident, a tragedy."

Brazill's father, a postal carrier who lives about 200 miles north in Daytona Beach, was performing volunteer work at his church when his cell phone rang. It was his brother calling from Lake Worth.

"I immediately began to pray that it wasn't actually Nate they were talking about," said the father, who is also named Nathaniel Brazill. "What made me realize it was true was my father got on the phone and he was crying."

Hoped to join Secret Service

The elder Brazill called his son a "bookworm" who wasn't interested in athletics but loved to read and talk and joke around. He was teaching his 2-year-old sister, Ebony, the ABCs, the parents said.

The honor roll student and budding musician also had ambitions to become a Secret Service agent for the president, they said.

Since the shooting, both said they have been trying to offer support and care.

"We don't talk about what happened," the boy's father said. "We are just trying to comfort him and assure him we are here for him."

When they visit the teenager at the juvenile detention center where he is awaiting a grand jury hearing, they talk about family and pray.

Told classmate of plan

According to police, a female classmate said Nathaniel told her as he was leaving that he was going to come back and shoot the counselor who suspended him.

"Just watch, I'll be all over the news," he told her, Police Chief William Smith said Wednesday.

The boy's court-appointed attorney, Randy Berman, said he understands the teen liked one of the girls in Grunow's room. Maybe Brazill just wanted to impress them by showing off the gun, Berman said.

"When Grunow confronted him, he could have pulled it out and it accidentally went off," Berman said.

No matter the circumstance, the boy is not an adult who deserves to go to prison, the elder Brazill said.

"He's a child. He's still a child," he said.
 
So, to summarize:

He stole a gun. Got sent home, which made him mad enough to return to Mr. Grunow's classroom with the gun. After bragging that he was going to shoot Mr. Grunow and be in the papers, he got close to him on the pretext of wanting to talk to someone else, pulled out the gun, pointed it at Mr. Grunow's face and fired it.

And both his mother and his lawyer claim it was an "accident."

"Polly Powell rushed home when she saw reports of a shooting at her son's school on television. She knew 13-year-old Nathaniel Brazill had been sent home for throwing water balloons, and she was concerned for his welfare."

If Mom knew poor young Nathaniel had been sent home, why was he all alone? Standard operating procedure I bet. Concerned for his welfare? Doesn't sound like it to me; father lives two hundred miles away.

Poor kid, to have such parents and grandparents. How long had Grandpa's loaded gun been missing, I wonder?

"Since the shooting, both said they have been trying to offer support and care.

'We don't talk about what happened,' the boy's father said. 'We are just trying to comfort him and assure him we are here for
him.'"

Sounds like the kid's never going to come to believe he did anything wrong. He just had an "accident."
 
Another example of how well these "Gun Safe School Zones" are working since they've been enacted into law ... if you do the crime, you do the time!
 
... and, a great example of how the media plays into all of this. They turn all of these kids into celebrities.

The real problem is, we have too much media / news, and it is too accessible ... but, of course, the media would rather blame it all on guns.

Damn shame this happened, but an 'accident'? That explanation really sets off the BS meter.

Regards from AZ
 
Again, we have angry youth,the cause,
left in day care from birth,one parent
homes, television, schools full of liberal
ideas,no discipline,not taught how to
read,self control,right and wrong.It is
sad and I sure don't know how to change
it however if we don't the future will
be very grim.

------------------
 
Actually it could be an accident . I don't know how many times I've pointed a loaded gun at something and pulled the trigger NOT MEANING FOR IT TO GO OFF ( PULLEEEZE ) and it has . I can't wait for the " smart gun " to come out in a store near me . The bullet pauses and decides if the target should be hit . If the target does not deserve to be hit the bullet falls to the floor . How about a 15 day waiting period on the firing pin to make contact .
Accident ? Yeah right !! Like a girl in my old high school that got an abortion . Said it wasn't her kid .

------------------
TOM
SASS AMERICAN LEGION NRA
 
Secret Service. He'll probably get the job. Hillary will need his kind - never to blame for what he does. (Scary thought).
 
My God!! this makes me sick.
The kid and everyone who he told what he was going to do should be charged. With all that has been happening in the world how do these kids hear what this kid told them and just ignore it. The kid's grandparents should be locked up as well.

------------------
"It is easier to get out of jail then it is a morgue"
Live long and defend yourself!
John 3:16
NRA lifer
GOA
GSSF
 
Maybe they will use the zero tolerance policy and Jesse jackson can come down and tell the media that the school is racist!

------------------
"We are fast approaching the stage of the ultimate inversion: the stage where the government is free to do anything it pleases, while the citizens may act only by permission; which is the stage of the darkest periods of human history, the stage of rule by brute force."

--Ayn Rand, in "The Nature of Government"
 
The kid stole the gun from his grandfather. Do you have any guns that someone could steal from your home without you realizing it was gone? Would they be loaded and ready to fire? How much responsibility does the grandfather bear in this? Any at all?

The media is quick to say that this kid was a great kid. They are slow to investigate the truth about how he was perceived by the other teachers and students. They leap at the chance to report the mother saying , "He loved that teacher."

A 13 year old is capable of formulating the intent to commit a crime. This may be tragic, but it was no accident. Wasted potential is a tradgedy, but so is the taking of an innocent human life.
 
<BLOCKQUOTE><font size="1" face="Verdana, Arial">quote:</font><HR>"Just watch, I'll be all over the news," he told her, [/quote]

Excuse me, but are we the only people to see a trend here?

The insatiable appetite of the nightly news may not be a prime factor in this murder, but it runs a damn close second place.

LawDog
 
<BLOCKQUOTE><font size="1" face="Verdana, Arial">quote:</font><HR>"When Grunow confronted him, he could have pulled it out and it accidentally went off,"[/quote]

Yeah, right! how many times have I heard that one??!!

Too true MountainGun, I myself was getting into all kinds of trouble at age 13. I knew darned well what I was doing and didn't give a crap!

One more thing: I hate the media!

------------------
"At last we shall reveal ourselves to the Gun-Grabbers, at last we shall have revenge at The TFL End of Summer Meet on August 12 & 13, 2000..."

[This message has been edited by Darthmaum (edited June 02, 2000).]
 
No one has ever shot anyone "by accident." Either there's intent, or negligence, but NEVER "by accident."

So I suppose we should all give the kid a hug and a pat on the head, and tell him not to kill anyone else, eh?

(Where th' hell is that puking smiley...)
 
I suggest that we all re-read "Matteo Falcone" by Prosper Merrime. I read it as a kid and did not get the point of the story. I did get it when I re-read it recently.

Oleg
 
The kid's leaving to get the gun, his reported boast that he was going to shoot someone, and the way he stole it well before the shooting, all sound like premeditation to me. "Premeditated accident" is a contracdiction in terms.
 
A few tidbits of interest, from the local paper.

The gun has been reported as stored unlocked, but unloaded with ammunition kept in a seperate location.

An ejected live CCI Blazer .25 Auto round was found at the crime scene, and the round in the chamber at the time Brazill surrendered had a "collapsed" primer. This would lead one to conclude that Brazill racked the slide after a jam or mistakenly reloaded the gun. Also, given the chambered round had failed to discharge after an apparent firing pin strike, the subject either intended to shoot Grunow again or someone else after the fatal shot.

"(H)e could have pulled it out and it accidentally went off," says his attorney. Perhaps it "accidentally" stole itself, loaded itself, concealed itself on his person then articulated itself three seperate times to perform the actions required for the facts described in the previous paragraph, also.
 
MountainGun44, any grandpa who shows a thirteen year old where he keeps his unlocked .32 and his ammo is insane to begin with, and more so if he doesn't keep track of them afterward.

Lawdog, your comments reminded me of a suggestion I heard once that the names of murderers _not_ be published in the newspaper, so as to deny them the publicity they crave. After the initial reports, refer to them as "the (accused) killer of . . ."

Also, deny them certain privileges of communication the rest of us take for granted. Go to Charlie Manson's web site to see why.[puking smiley needed]
 
Here in lies the problem with our country nowadays, people not taking responsibilty for their actions. Gee, do you think this might have someting to with our president not taking responsibilty for his own actions.
 
What David Scott said about "Premeditated accident" reminded me of a good man gone.
Brother Dave Gardner. He was a comedian who looked at things a bit differently.

Dave said, "there's no such thing as an accident; it's all premeditated carelessness."
I think it bears some validity.
 
Back
Top