towncarblue
i am willing to give up on the NEW part ... but i want a SNUB NOSE revolver...
i do not know how a 357mag would shoot as a snub
i would be willing to get a slightly smaller caliber if its as good as a 357mag....
I shoot a 640-1 j frame snub now in 357 mag. I can be pretty fast and accurate with it. I feel very comfortable with this as my CCW, except the reload...mine is magnaported. Recoil is harsh, but return to target times are good. Additionally, the S&W trigger is great.
I also have a S&W 19-3 4" in 357 mag. The recoil is less harsh and accuracy is great....like maybe best of all my pistols! Since it is a K frame, it won't see any H110 180 gr loads, but I do enjoy moderate 90% full velocity 158 gr loads. It is a real shooter and pretty blue.
A J frame snubby, especially a 340PD is HARSH, but some people can shoot them well. I feel I can.
A K frame snubby's larger grip should make this quite pleasant. Personally, I would love a 3" 13-3 cerakoted black!
I would have no issue buying a 70's production 13,19,65,66 if I can check it out. They were good guns.
If you want to shoot hotter loads, an N frame would be a better choice as there is a rare, but documented issue with K frames cracking or gas cutting in the thinnest part of the forcing cone.