Legal Question,

Looks like federal prison for you and your buddy, plus the lifetime loss of gun rights. What might have started as a lawful temporary loan (if anyone believes you about your intent) becomes just a garden variety, unlawful transfer from a resident of one State to a resident of another.
Click to expand...

Not me - it's a hypothetical question :)

At what point would the crime have been committed though? It can't have been at the time the firearm was transferred, since that was a temporary loan. Can something I did in the past - that was legal at the time I did it - become a crime later? That doesn't sound right!
 
Seems like it would be the moment the transfer ceased to be for "temporary use for lawful sporting purposes." So, the first time someone says, "Nah, just keep it" would likely be the point a law is clearly broken.
 
divil said:
...Can something I did in the past - that was legal at the time I did it - become a crime later?....
Click to expand...
But that's not what's happening here.

  1. Was handing the guy the gun in the first place legal?

    Well, you say it was a qualifying temporary loan. But considering what happened later, that might be a tough story for the U. S. Attorney/federal grand jury/judge/jury at your trial to swallow. Is there any evidence corroborating the spin you're trying to put on the deal?

    Bottom line is that no one has to believe you. People being investigated for criminal conduct make up all kinds of exculpating stories

  2. But taking the most charitable possible view of the story, there are really two acts.

    The first act was when you first handed your buddy your gun for what you now say was a loan satisfying the criteria necessary to make it legal.

    The second act was when the purpose for which the loan was made was fulfilled and you didn't take the gun back. This second act would be the crime.

    Let's say that there was no purpose for the loan, the fulfillment of which would be an identifiable event. In that case your prospects of selling the lawful loan story look pretty bleak.
 
Sometime soon after the sporting event was over is probably when the law is broken. Maybe they would have to have the gun back to its original owner within a few days. Just my guess
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top