LCR for my girlfriend, 9mm, .357 or .38 spl?

For the advocates of 9mm, do you have any load data? While it may have an edge in velocity over the .38, the .38 allows for deeper hollow point cavities and bullet designs that expand better.

Honestly, I've never been impressed with the accuracy of 9mm out of revolvers, and the recoil is annoying.
 
.38 or 9

If it were my wife, I would recommend the .38 LCRx due to its smaller size frame, and the 9 if the slightly bigger size didn't matter. Then let her try them both and choose. She would not shoot .357 ammo in an LCR, so why buy the .357 size gun? It is more logical to go with the smaller .38, or the larger 9 that she could enjoy shooting, with cheaper ammo being a bonus.
<edit> However, if she didn't like the kick of the .38, then .38 in the .357 frame might be her preference. My guess is she would prefer the .38LCRx, since she likes my SP101 in single action.
 
Last edited:
I can't speak for the load data of 9mm out of a revolver, since most statistics I've seen are for pistol barrel (no cylinder gap). However, you get FBI standard penetration out of modern (and some non-modern) 9mm hollow points... It's pretty much assumed by most reasonable people that 9mm is adequate for self-defense. It's almost the same with regards to penetration when compared with similar offerings (same companies, same bullet-type) in .40 S&W and .45 ACP: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c8gm7ZTkDxc

The above video is "tnoutdoors9," while though he is not a ballistics expert, he does some really good, fairly scientific tests. You can watch scores of them, and .40 S&W, .45 ACP, and 9mm are all pretty similar when you get down to it. This makes sense, because when you compare the ft/lbs of energy between the major offerings of these calibers, they are all around the 300-400 ft/lbs mark. Yes, you can find more ft/lbs in .40 and .45 ACP than 9mm, but really those are the exceptions to the rule of production calibers...

So, I don't believe you are really going to see much of a difference between .38 SPL and 9mm, at least not one that would concern you in a gunfight or at the range. If you feel you NEED to shoot .38 SPL, go ahead and pay more money to do so. I'll stick with 9mm and be happier and better trained for it.

People have been saying that the 9mm kicks more than .38. Well, that probably is not an issue as the 9mm gun weighs more.

As far as 9mm accuracy is concerned... my 986 is probably one of the most accurate pistols I've ever shot, caliber aside. There is no reason why 9mm can't be accurate out of a revolver, but really? That's not going to matter in a sub-nosed revolver, any caliber you are spitting out of it.

And moon clips? Moon clips of 9mm are the easiest, fastest reload you will ever get out of a revolver short of .45 ACP in moon clips. You'd have the best chance under stress conditions loading a fixed clip than anything else.
 
Just keep in mind, when you suggest the .22 LR or .22 WRM versions of the LCR, they have pretty different triggers than the centerfire versions of the gun. The rimfire versions necessitate a heavier pull because of the cartridge that most people do not appreciate. The centerfire versions have much nicer triggers...

...not that the rimfire versions are awful. I've just seen them returned, and even older shooters who say that pulling the trigger hurts their finger (or they simply can't) on rimfire versions of the gun. I didn't know this, until somebody pointed it out to me and I was able to compare the triggers. It's pretty significant. SP101's in rimfire seem to have nicer triggers (on the ones I've tried).
 
Went through this more then twenty years ago with my mother. Her first gun was the same as my fathers a Bersa .380 with a double stack mag. She shot it fine even though it did not fit her hand correctly. They had a break in and insurance was paying for the replacements so I took her down to the LGS and she picked out what fit her hand. For her it was an Airweight enclosed hammer in .38 Special and she carries it every day and when dad and I go fishing she has it on the bead stand right above her head with two quickloaders just in case things go bump in the night.
 
Back
Top