Keeping my wife alive

Magnum Wheel Man said:
a local families murderer's trial ended just reciently... the intruder killed several of the household members in the middle of the night, with their own shotgun...

it's assumed that the bad guy took the shotgun away from one of the family members & then shot them with their own shotgun...

yes, the shotgun is easier to use... but it's also easier to take away, if the bad guy gets too close

I've always wondered why the "conventional wisdom" is that for home defense:
  • A long barreled handgun is "bad" because it is slow to swing and also can be grabbed at close range
  • The shotgun (which is a lot slower and easier to grab) is the "ultimate weapon"
 
If she's having trouble shooting a DA pistol, you might want to teach her how to shoot SA....or even get her a SA revolver. SA revolvers usually have great triggers out of the box (better than most DA revolvers/pistols), and they can be had in effective calibers from .38SPL up to .44Mag. Reloads are slower than DA revolvers or semi-autos...but not as slow as one thinks.

You may also want to interest her in a lever-action carbine in a pistol caliber....or, if she's very recoil-sensitive, a Ruger 10-22 with a 25+rd. mag full of HV loads. One .22lr Velocitor may not stop a bad guy...but 25 of them will certainly catch his attention....
 
CC

Carbine Caleb,

I've always wondered why the "conventional wisdom" is that for home defense:

* A long barreled handgun is "bad" because it is slow to swing and also can be grabbed at close range
* The shotgun (which is a lot slower and easier to grab) is the "ultimate weapon"


Well, I've said it before, The shotgun is the weapon of choice of the ensconced defender. Take cover behind cover or at least concealment and LOUDLY announce to the intruder that if they come through your doorway, they will be shot. Next, you have to actually follow through with that. Aimed at the door, if someone attempts entry without identification/authorization from you, you shoot them before they can get close enough to grab your weapon.

In FoF classes and in Defensive Long Gun class, we have defenders playing themselves with a Simunitions equipped shotgun. If they get all monkey brained during the scenario, I am more than happy to take the gun away from them. I had one student doing everything fine then a switch turned and he advanced screaming "You want a piece of this?" I proceeded to take the gun from him and then the ref/ safety officer stopped the scenario and I asked him if he knew what he had just said. He had no knowledge of having gone monkey brain and needed multiple other students to confirm to him that is what happened.

If people are not trained and mentally prepared for using a long gun, they do stand the chance of having that gun taken from them just as they would a handgun. Problem is there is more gun to grab with a long gun. Another possibility is that the gun was not in the safe room with them and the intruder simply got to it first and used it on them. If a gun is for defense, it needs to be on you or very very handy, not in another room. AND, when you leave the immediate area for a while or for the day, the gun needs to be secured so it is not stolen or taken to be used against you.

MONKEY BRAIN: Monkey response to a fight, "move in, bash on head with rock" we now have tools that relieve us of that need to move in. Before, during and after the fight. Unfortunately, in times of panic/ high stress, people revert to monkey status.

As for the long barreled handgun, most likely thought there is the ability / comfort of carrying it on your person at all times. Although as an overweight / overage / male, I can conceal a 5" STI wide body without problem. Even in the summer here in Texas. I actually choose to carry an XD at the moment instead of the 2011 but I know it can and has been done. Not everyone has the <SARCASM> manly </SARCASM> physique to do this and that is where smaller guns / shorter barrels are more popular.
 
A long barreled handgun is "bad" because it is slow to swing and also can be grabbed at close range
The shotgun (which is a lot slower and easier to grab) is the "ultimate weapon"

There seems to be an assumption that if anyone breaks in, the homeowner will end up barricaded in the bedroom with a shotgun pointed at the door, waiting for the intruder. If this were true, a shotgun would be the "ultimate weapon". From news accounts I've read over the years, a more common scenario involves wrestling with the intruder and hopefully breaking away for a few seconds to grab a gun. I imagine it's difficult to use a shotgun while you're wrestling on the floor.

I don't know if anyone keeps stats on homeowner involved shootings. I read that in shootings where a police officer is killed, more than half occur from 5' or less: http://www.theppsc.org/Staff_Views/Aveni/OIS.pdf
 
Hello, all, and thanks for the good advice.

I dug up an old S&W Bodyguard Airweight with Tyler grip adapter; my wife has no problem with the trigger pull. Loaded with .38 wadcutters, I suspect it will be just the ticket for her. Light, concealable, no hammer spur to impede draw, and low enough recoil to enable follow-up shots with minimal problems.

Meanwhile, we've managed a technique for her to work the slide on semi-automatic pistols. Once she gets used to the 38, we'll see if she'd prefer something more potent, albeit heavier and perhaps with a more complex manual of arms.
 
shotgun?

There was a time when I worked/trained w/ female LE recruits/LEO's and the 12 ga pump shotgun, and w/ about 25% or so, (pure recall) it was NOT the weapon of choice.

Even w/ low recoil ammo, it can be too much kick. I have seen trainees ground the gun and leave the line in tears. Even if the lady has the heart of a lioness and can handle the recoil, she may lack the strength to manage a full size pump gun at 7-8 lbs in a shooting/point shoulder stance. Often, the shotguns, were all too long in the stock, length of pull, and needed to be substantially shortened to be mounted correctly. Finally, although interested in self defense, most were not gun girls and the manual of arms/ management of the firearm: slide release, tube mag, safety, etc, was too complicated to master, given the time frame.

What worked as a long gun was the M1 or M4 carbine.


Hand strength and the DA revolver, in those days usually Smith K's or Ruger Sec-6, was also an issue. It was not uncommon for a lady to not be able to cycle the DA trigger w/ 0 two fingers, ie, one w/ each hand. If for some reason a two handgrip was not achievable (injury, fending off attacker, carrying or grasping an object of importance like a railing to prevent a fall) and reduced to one hand shooting, they were effectively unarmed.

The .22 auto is looking better than nothing in instances like that.
 
chaplain tom said:
No offense taken, but I think you may have taken my comments out of context or maybe just misunderstood me.

You didn't say that your wife was acting macho, but I got that from what you said she said: "My wife actually told me to shut up and let her shoot the damn things." I generally interpret such a response from a beginner to safety-related warnings as macho--whether the person is male or female makes no difference to me. Other things you said about her probably would have been interpreted by some people as macho if she were male, and as tough because she is female, but like I said gender makes no difference to me. In fact, a bunch of people in this thread seem to automatically assume that all males are macho, even if they don't act all tough.

Now, if I totally misinterpreted what you were saying in this context, and got the wrong impression, then I guess none of what I said earlier applies to your wife (obviously you know her a lot better than I do). What you said just reminded me of my sister, who often is more macho than I am. I'm a guy, but I'm neither embarrassed nor ashamed to admit that I still have some real fear of guns, and I think it helps me be as safe as I can be. Most would call this type of fear "respect" and I can understand the reason for doing that, but respect means nothing without the genuine fear of getting hurt or killed backing it up. My sister apparently has no such fear, and thinks I'm overreacting every time I yell at her for sweeping me with the muzzle (by accident, but it's still careless), just because her finger is off the trigger. :rolleyes: To me, that's a macho attitude.

chaplain tom said:
All I was saying is that some if not most women ARE tougher than we give them credit for.

Some women are, and some aren't. Some guys are macho, and some aren't. Some women are macho, too--just like guys acting tougher than perhaps they are or lacking the proper "respect" for tools that can maim or kill when mishandled. The percentages are going to be different between the genders, and I understand the point that is being made, and agree with it, but when it comes to individuals I try to ignore things like gender or race, for example, as best I can because they only tell us the probabilities, not the facts about the individual.

chaplain tom said:
My wife basically told me that she was not afraid of the guns and that she would like to make up her own mind about which one she wanted to shoot. She was not getting "macho" with me at all. She said that while she appreciated my warnings about a particular gun's power, recoil, and noise she didn't want me to say too much because she wanted to find out for herself and make up her own mind.

That's a lot clearer to me than what you said earlier. It's not your fault, though--I think that you expected your statements to be interpreted in a certain light, but I guess I shut that particular light off in my own head. ;)

chaplain tom said:
I agree that sometimes this does not work out this way. My father taught me how to shoot, but he had no success with my brother. He was too close and went about it all wrong with him. He pushed him too hard and teased him about things better left alone. Sometimes the ones closest to us are the wrong ones to try to teach us. Not the case with my wife and I.

It's good that you both can be so up-front with each other in such matters, because what I described in my previous post is all too common between those who are close, as you also just said. It's not that certain individuals are necessarily macho in general, but I guess they can't stand the idea of learning from somebody whom they perceive as their equal--and want to be perceived by as their equal.

Please accept my apology for misinterpreting what you said regarding your wife...although I do think that you were trying to make your wife seem tough in how you said it, which to me looks macho. ;) I'm sure that everybody else knew exactly what you meant, but I see things differently than most.
 
A good dog. Not some bite trained GSD, unless thats what you want, but pretty much any dog. Working breed if you guys can take it for daily walks. Labs are good companions and have a loud bark.

And Im sure some one will give me flack, FN5.7. Why? Very easy to shoot, light recoil, 20+1. The 5.7x28 will take down a attacker. Ive killed 250lb hogs with ss197. Loaded with Eilite Ammo Im sure it would do whats needed.
 
Back
Top